![]() |
| Verdi’s Messa da Requiem honours Manzoni through a musical sequence that moves from prayers for eternal rest and the terrors of judgement to the personal appeal of the Libera me. |
Work Information
- Composer: Giuseppe Verdi (1813–1901)
- Title:
- Messa da Requiem
- Year of composition:
- 1873–1874; earlier Libera me, 1869
- First performance:
- 22 May 1874, San Marco, Milan; conducted by Giuseppe Verdi
- Genre:
- Requiem — setting of the liturgy for the dead
- Musical Period:
- Romanticism
- Structure:
- Seven principal movements; extensive internal divisions in the Dies irae
- Duration:
- approx. 75–90 minutes
- Instrumentation:
- Soprano, mezzo-soprano, tenor and bass soloists; mixed chorus, divided into two four-part choirs in the Sanctus; large orchestra with woodwind, brass, timpani, bass drum and strings. Four additional distant trumpets are used in the Tuba mirum.
- Dedication:
- In memory of Alessandro Manzoni (1785–1873)
- Text:
- Latin liturgical texts; Kyrie eleison in Greek
- Revision:
- New setting of Liber scriptus for mezzo-soprano, 1875
Giuseppe Verdi’s Messa da Requiem is a large-scale setting of the Catholic liturgy for the dead, written for four soloists, chorus and orchestra. Composed in memory of Alessandro Manzoni, the author of The Betrothed, it received its first performance in 1874. Its expressive range grows from the encounter between an inherited sacred text and a composer with an exceptional command of the musical means of fear, repentance and supplication. The famous eruption of the Dies irae represents only one aspect of a work that asks for equally attentive listening at its quietest dynamic levels.
Manzoni occupied a place of moral and cultural authority in Verdi’s imagination. The composer’s admiration was bound up with Italian literature, language and the cultural identity of the recently unified nation; it should not be mistaken for a close personal friendship. Following the writer’s death on 22 May 1873, Verdi proposed composing and conducting a memorial Mass on the first anniversary. The premiere took place at San Marco in Milan, with Teresa Stolz, Maria Waldmann, Giuseppe Capponi and Ormondo Maini as the soloists. Within days the work moved to La Scala, beginning its long passage between church and concert hall.
The music’s history reaches further back. The concluding Libera me developed from Verdi’s contribution to a collaborative Mass in Rossini’s memory in 1869. He returned to that earlier composition and revised it when undertaking his own complete Requiem. Nor did the score cease to evolve after its premiere. In 1875 he replaced the original choral Liber scriptus with the familiar mezzo-soprano solo. This revision belongs to the established version normally performed today.
Questions about theatricality have accompanied the Requiem from the beginning. Its sustained melodic lines, abrupt contrasts and demanding solo writing belong unmistakably to Verdi’s musical experience in the theatre. Alongside them, the sequence of liturgical texts, the collective presence of the chorus, unaccompanied singing and extended fugues create a different kind of musical continuity. The singers have no fixed characters to portray, and there is no stage plot. A voice can describe the Last Judgement, confess guilt and then join a prayer for the repose of others.
Understanding the work means following how these changing positions are connected across its considerable span. The returns of the Dies irae, the shifting combinations of voices and the reappearance of the opening prayer in the final movement establish relationships between widely separated moments. Each section retains its own identity, while the listener is encouraged to remember what has already been heard. By the end, the last appeal carries the accumulated weight of the entire work.
Movements / Structure
The Requiem has seven principal movements. The second, the extended Dies irae sequence, contains numerous internal sections and occupies roughly half the work’s duration. The outline below distinguishes that large-scale design from the smaller divisions often presented as individual tracks on recordings.
| Movement | Opening tempo / design | Vocal forces | Place in the overall design |
|---|---|---|---|
| I. Requiem e Kyrie | Andante; subsequent tempo changes | Chorus and four soloists | Rest for the dead and an invocation of mercy. |
| II. Dies irae | Opening Allegro agitato; numerous internal tempi | Chorus and varying combinations of the four soloists | Judgement, individual petitions and the Lacrymosa. |
| III. Offertorio | Andante mosso; internal contrasts | Four soloists only | Domine Jesu Christe, Quam olim Abrahae and Hostias. |
| IV. Sanctus | Allegro | Two four-part choirs | Praise in an eight-part fugal setting. |
| V. Agnus Dei | Andante | Soprano, mezzo-soprano and chorus | A recurring melody, octave singing and changing accompaniment. |
| VI. Lux aeterna | Molto moderato | Mezzo-soprano, tenor and bass | Eternal light, with contrasts of register and colour. |
| VII. Libera me | Moderato; senza misura and later changes | Soprano and chorus | Recitation, returns of Dies irae and Requiem aeternam, concluding fugue. |
Following the long sequence of judgement, the next four movements repeatedly change the vocal forces: the solo quartet alone in the Offertorio, double chorus in the Sanctus, the two female soloists and chorus in the Agnus Dei, and a trio without soprano in the Lux aeterna. The final Libera me adds a responsory from the burial rites beyond the Mass itself. Its position allows the music to reconsider earlier events rather than concluding with the Communion’s vision of eternal light.
Musical Analysis
I. Requiem e Kyrie — Giving Voice to the Prayer
The Requiem begins by asking for rest through a few softly sounding lines. Muted cellos start alone with a slow descending figure in A minor. The mutes soften the instruments’ brilliance, giving their tone a restrained colour. Other strings enter before the chorus, and the sparse texture allows each arrival to be heard separately. Verdi introduces the resources of his large ensemble gradually, making a quiet instrumental line the starting point for the voices that follow.
At Requiem aeternam dona eis, Domine—“Grant them eternal rest, Lord”—the chorus enters ppp sottovoce. Restrained tone and precisely coordinated consonants are essential to the expression. The phrase acquires its weight through collective articulation, sustained notes and small harmonic changes. The ear is drawn towards the care with which the words are pronounced, rather than towards an immediately imposing choral sonority. The request for rest sounds like speech being deliberately shaped.
The Te decet hymnus changes the relationship between voices and instruments. The unaccompanied chorus moves more actively, its successive entries suggesting an older ecclesiastical manner. The shift is audible in the disappearance of orchestral support and the greater independence of the vocal lines. A return of Requiem aeternam restores the subdued opening character. The Introit thus acquires an internal design, with a contrasting choral passage enclosed by related outer sections.
The tenor introduces Kyrie eleison, bringing an individual voice into the prayer for mercy. The melody unfolds in longer phrases, while A major changes the harmonic colour around the same keynote as the opening A minor. The other soloists enter in turn, allowing each vocal colour to register before it joins the ensemble. Their phrases overlap, complement one another and connect with the chorus. The same brief plea can consequently be heard as an individual utterance and as a collective request.
The contrapuntal working of the Kyrie preserves the immediacy of its melody. Different lines can be heard as related forms of the same appeal, while the orchestra supports the growth and recession of the sound. The movement broadens, reaches its climaxes and subsides. Before the second movement begins, a complete progression has already taken place from an almost imperceptible instrumental opening to a communal invocation of mercy. The next eruption is so disruptive partly because that earlier progression has been given time to establish itself.
II. Dies irae — Judgement and the Changing Voices of Supplication
The Dies irae is the Requiem’s longest and most internally varied movement. It sets the medieval Latin sequence for the Day of Judgement, whose text moves from a description of universal catastrophe to personal guilt and a plea for salvation. Verdi responds to those changing perspectives through successive vocal combinations. Massed chorus, solitary voice, trio and duet reveal different dimensions of the fear expressed in the text.
Dies irae, Tuba mirum and Mors stupebit
The opening eruption in G minor depends on repeated orchestral blows, forceful rhythmic attacks and rapid string figuration. The bass drum adds a depth of impact distinct from the pitched sound of the timpani. The chorus delivers the words in a common rhythm, keeping the text intelligible within the dense texture. The impression of violent disturbance arises from the precise coordination of several kinds of movement: heavy blows, descending figures and insistently returning vocal articulation.
This music’s immediate force also has a structural purpose. The opening Dies irae establishes such a strong aural identity that its later returns can be recognised at once. The listener need not retain a long melody: the orchestral attack, rhythm and manner of choral delivery are enough. That recognisability enables Verdi to interrupt subsequent pleas with the remembered presence of judgement. Recollection becomes a means of connecting the sequence’s contrasting episodes.
In the Tuba mirum, the summons of the trumpet acquires an actual spatial dimension. The score calls for four additional trumpets in the distance, alongside the four in the orchestra. Calls sound from a separate position, answer one another and gather into a steadily increasing concentration of brass. Distance becomes part of the musical construction. By the time the chorus enters, this expanding instrumental field has prepared the scale of the event described in the words.
The Mors stupebit abruptly reduces that enormous scale. The bass soloist describes death and nature standing astonished before the resurrection of the dead. Slow delivery and the spaces around the repeated words Mors stupebit make arrested motion an audible feature. Following the accumulation of the Tuba mirum, an isolated voice and restrained accompaniment give particular weight to a phrase that seems unable to continue freely.
Liber scriptus, Quid sum miser and Rex tremendae
In the established version of Liber scriptus, the mezzo-soprano announces the book in which the evidence for judgement is recorded. Her line has the authority of a public proclamation: clear verbal emphasis, decisive attacks and phrases that can expand with considerable vocal presence. Quiet choral interventions on Dies irae keep the threat active beneath the solo. A return of the opening eruption then enlarges the sound again and reconnects the episode with the beginning of the sequence.
At Quid sum miser—“What shall I, a wretch, say then?”—the sound contracts to three soloists: soprano, mezzo-soprano and tenor. The bass voice is absent, and a bassoon can be distinguished within the sparse accompaniment. Shorter phrases bring the singers together in a shared petition. The change of scale follows a change in the words: after the announcement of the book of judgement, an individual asks who could speak in their defence. Soft dynamics and the smaller vocal group give that question a more personal delivery.
The Rex tremendae is organised around two contrasting kinds of utterance. Forceful choral addresses to the king of fearful majesty encounter the melodic appeal salva me—“save me”. Soloists and chorus do not remain permanently opposed; their relationships change as the passage unfolds. Authority and the need for mercy receive different rhythmic weight, dynamic emphasis and phrase lengths. The listener can follow these layers drawing closer as the initial grandeur increasingly gives way to supplication.
Recordare, Ingemisco and Confutatis
The Recordare for soprano and mezzo-soprano is one of the sequence’s most sustained lyrical developments. The singers move between alternation and simultaneous singing, often in closely related melodic lines. The text asks Christ to remember the purpose of his incarnation and suffering, and the music allows the words to unfold in phrases requiring an unbroken breath. Orchestral continuity connects the entries, sustaining the movement as one singer completes a thought and the other takes it up.
In the Ingemisco, repentance is voiced by the tenor. The opening admission of guilt grows into a more expansive plea as the melody rises and the orchestra becomes more active. The lyrical writing differentiates the text rather than giving every word the same expressive weight. The recollection of forgiveness granted to Mary and to the thief creates room for hope; the wish to be placed among the saved directs the passage towards its culmination. Vocal display has a clear dramatic function within the prayer.
In Confutatis, the bass soloist first describes the condemned and then asks to be called among the blessed at voca me cum benedictis. One singer carries both sides of the contrast. Forceful, rhythmically insistent delivery gives way to a quieter, more connected phrase, with a corresponding change in the orchestral support. The altered manner of singing makes the turn towards supplication audible. This differs from Mozart’s setting of the same text, where the opposition between male and female choral voices is a central feature.
The Return of the Dies irae and the Lacrymosa
After the Confutatis, the return of the opening Dies irae temporarily overturns the distance created by the lyrical episodes. It also brings back the accumulated weight of its earlier appearances. The petitions have been heard, yet fear remains present. This recognisable interruption gives the sequence cohesion: the listener hears an extended movement shaped by departure and return, rather than a succession of self-contained solo numbers.
The Lacrymosa finally redirects the music towards collective lamentation. Its characteristic dotted accompaniment, recurring melodic movement and successive solo entries establish a steadier, persistent flow. B-flat minor and chromatic tension reinforce the gravity of the words, while the arrival of the chorus expands the expression beyond individual voices. Careful legato is crucial: the passage’s intensity depends on the continuity of the lament and the gradual shaping of its climaxes. The concluding prayer, Pie Jesu Domine, dona eis requiem, brings the sequence back to the repose of the dead.
III. Offertorio — The Prayer of the Solo Quartet
The Offertorio changes the acoustic scale after the long sequence of judgement. The chorus is silent throughout, and the text is entrusted exclusively to the four soloists. Without the collective vocal mass, differences between individual voices and small instrumental interventions become more apparent. An opening cello melody prepares a flowing movement in A-flat major before the mezzo-soprano and tenor begin.
Domine Jesu Christe asks for the souls of the departed to be delivered from the dangers of the underworld. The gentler opening does not remove the text’s dramatic content. References to the lion, the abyss and darkness generate local disturbances through increased vocal pressure, stronger harmonic movement and changes of density. A particularly luminous moment arrives with the soprano’s high entry at sed signifer sanctus Michael. The change of register introduces a new perspective within the petition as the words speak of leading souls into holy light.
The promise to Abraham in Quam olim Abrahae brings quicker movement and imitative writing. One singer begins a melodic figure and another takes it up while the first line continues. These overlapping entries thicken the texture without obscuring the soloists’ separate lines. Following the start of a phrase and hearing it reappear in another voice is enough to recognise the process. Its greater activity distinguishes this passage from the movement’s flowing opening and gives the listener a clear point of reference when it returns.
The Hostias restores a slower pace and a more open texture. The tenor presents the offering of sacrifices and prayers, with carefully chosen wind colours audible around his line. The orchestration’s sensitivity is especially apparent when a melodic phrase can reach its end without being covered by a dense accompaniment. A return of Quam olim Abrahae joins the movement’s different regions. The same musical promise is heard after the offering, establishing an intelligible internal point of return.
The movement’s position within the Requiem also helps explain its performing demands. The four singers need the directness of solo delivery alongside the attentiveness of a chamber ensemble. Balance, shared breath and connected phrasing allow the music to remain mobile without making every rise in intensity sound like an operatic climax. Following the dramatic sequence, this smaller scale gives the listener time to hear how one voice affects the continuation of another.
IV. Sanctus — Eight Choral Voices in Motion
The Sanctus restores the chorus in a character quite distinct from the violence of the Dies irae. A short brass proclamation prepares the fast movement in F major. Successive vocal entries set the texture in motion, adding lines rather than relying on a single block of sound. The words of praise meet music sustained by the active participation of the whole ensemble.
The heading Fuga a due Cori specifies two four-part choirs, each with soprano, alto, tenor and bass voices. A fugue introduces a recognisable subject in successive voices while the lines already in progress continue. Here that process extends across both choral groups: entries follow and overlap one another, gradually drawing the ensemble together. Eight vocal parts do not mean eight equally prominent melodies sounding independently at every moment. Changes between lighter and denser combinations help the subject remain audible within the large ensemble.
Rapid syllables and compact melodic units provide a clear rhythmic impetus. The word Sanctus returns in successive positions, making new entries recognisable even when it is difficult to follow every voice. At Pleni sunt coeli and Hosanna, local changes in density and in the interaction of the two choirs give the continuous movement different degrees of emphasis. The praise has a lively internal organisation, rather than a single unvarying intensity.
The orchestra helps make that organisation audible. It supports entries, contributes rhythmic energy and reinforces moments when different lines converge. An excessively heavy choral sound can conceal the speed of the exchanges. Vocal agility and clear articulation allow the counterpoint to be heard as action. Although this is the shortest of the seven principal movements, it decisively changes the work’s proportions: for a few minutes, the collective voice sustains an uninterrupted, closely organised act of praise.
V. Agnus Dei — One Melody, a Changing Scale of Sound
The transition into the Agnus Dei brings one of the Requiem’s clearest changes of texture. After the eight choral parts and orchestral activity of the Sanctus, soprano and mezzo-soprano begin unaccompanied, in parallel octaves. They sing the same melodic line at different pitches. The octave preserves the distinct identity of the two voices, while their exact agreement in rhythm and melodic direction presents the petition as a shared utterance.
The melody begins in C major, without instrumental accompaniment. Both singers move together in the same rhythm, often through small melodic steps, while the longer notes allow the words to remain clear. This spare, single-line delivery can suggest ecclesiastical chant. That resemblance describes an audible quality; it does not establish a quotation from a particular Gregorian melody. Verdi’s own line is organised in regular metre and carries detailed instructions for phrasing and expression.
| Example 1. Agnus Dei, bars 1–4: the two solo vocal staves; the opening unaccompanied melody in octaves. Source: Giuseppe Verdi, Messa da Requiem, ed. David Rosen, University of Chicago Press / Ricordi, 1990, p. 184; digitised copy IMSLP 759892. |
The first excerpt shows the same movement in both voices, with the soprano one octave above the mezzo-soprano. The marking dolcissimo and the shared phrasing ask for particular care in the connection of the notes. The melody needs to sound unified, without differences of vocal colour producing conflicting accents or pacing. Even a listener who does not read notation can hear two singers moving together without an independent accompanying line.
The choral answer from bar 14 retains the essential melody but changes the breadth of the sound. The four choral groups present the line in octaves while the orchestra adds harmonic support. Only the choral staves appear in the second excerpt; the instrumental accompaniment lies outside the crop. The comparison shows how an expansion of musical scale can take place without introducing a new tune. The same request acquires a different weight when it passes from two individuals to the larger ensemble.
| Example 2. Agnus Dei, bars 14–17: the four choral staves only; instrumental accompaniment is not reproduced. Source: Giuseppe Verdi, Messa da Requiem, ed. David Rosen, University of Chicago Press / Ricordi, 1990, p. 184; digitised copy IMSLP 759892. |
The movement unfolds through successive repetitions and variations of this relationship. Harmonic changes, turns towards the minor and new colours in the accompaniment differentiate the invocations. The singers do not have to make every return louder: altered support and distribution can themselves produce a new shade of expression. Here the liturgical text asks for rest—dona eis requiem, eventually requiem sempiternam—in place of the peace requested in the ordinary Mass’s Agnus Dei. The repeated return to that appeal helps explain the movement’s economy of material.
VI. Lux aeterna — Three Voices for Eternal Light
The Lux aeterna, the Communion text of the Mass for the Dead, is assigned to mezzo-soprano, tenor and bass. Soprano and chorus are absent. That choice distinguishes its sound from the clear melodic agreement of the Agnus Dei and, through the soprano’s absence, prepares her prominent reappearance in the final movement. A listener following the distribution of voices can hear the work continually renewing the resources available to it.
The mezzo-soprano begins the invocation of eternal light above muted violins, divided into separate lines in a high register. Their very soft dynamic leaves the voice clearly audible, while tremolo—the rapid repetition of notes—keeps a fine movement running beneath it. B-flat major establishes the opening harmonic area. The combination of a sustained vocal line and a moving instrumental background gives this passage its distinctive sound before the text and vocal group change.
The bass’s entry at Requiem aeternam turns towards B-flat minor. Bassoons and low brass replace the opening’s light accompaniment with a weightier colour. The keynote remains the same, but the shift from major to minor, together with the lowest solo voice, audibly changes the character. Light and rest consequently receive different musical settings within the movement. Once the tenor joins them, the three soloists can exchange phrases and come together in shared appeals.
The movement’s progress depends on alternating and gradually connecting these regions. It contains increases in intensity, harmonic movement and returns of the principal verbal appeals. Its eventual withdrawal allows the next solitary voice to register more directly. After the prayer for eternal light, the first person of Libera me will explicitly restore individual apprehension. The transition depends as much on the changing disposition of voices as on the words themselves.
VII. Libera me — The Final Appeal and the Memory of the Work
The Libera me begins with the soprano’s appeal Libera me, Domine, de morte aeterna—“Deliver me, Lord, from eternal death.” The instruction senza misura, without a strictly measured pulse, gives the words a freedom close to recitative. Repeated pitches and small melodic movements focus attention on verbal articulation. The chorus enters quietly, taking up and enlarging the individual plea.
At Tremens factus sum ego, measured movement brings increasing anxiety. Repeated orchestral patterns underpin a vocal line that expands in range and intensity. The fear named in the text is connected to an audible process of accumulation: greater movement, increasing pressure within the phrase and stronger support. The return of the Dies irae emerges from this fresh dramatic preparation, restoring the unmistakable sound of judgement at the end of the work.
Its position is crucial to the large-scale design. The Offertorio, the praise of the Sanctus, the petitions of the Agnus Dei and the eternal light of the Lux aeterna have all intervened. The listener now recognises the opening music across a considerable distance and within another text of the burial rites. Recollection becomes more powerful because the preceding movements have allowed the immediate sound of the Dies irae to recede.
Next comes Requiem aeternam for soprano and unaccompanied chorus. The prayer heard at the beginning returns in a different tonal area and without its original orchestral support. The soloist joins above the choral voices, reaching a demanding high register at a very soft dynamic. With no instruments present, variations in pitch and breathing are especially exposed. The calm continuity heard by the listener depends on sustained vocal support, shared phrasing and a carefully balanced ensemble.
The concluding fugue in C minor restarts the appeal Libera me with a clearly defined melodic and rhythmic subject. Successive entries allow the listener to follow the petition spreading through the chorus. The texture thickens as lines are added, and the soprano participates in the larger construction rather than remaining outside it as a solo commentator. The request for deliverance becomes an active collective undertaking, organised through counterpoint.
The fugue does not lead straight to the final chord. After its climaxes, the music reduces its activity and returns to a speech-like delivery of the petition. Soprano and chorus quietly repeat Libera me as the orchestra settles on C major. That major chord brings no celebratory increase in volume: the final morendo asks for the sound to die away. Harmonic closure and expressive character therefore need to be distinguished. The work ends with a hushed appeal, even though its concluding chord is major.
Three kinds of musical organisation are thus brought together in the last movement: free delivery of the text, recognisable returns of earlier music and sustained contrapuntal development. Its continuity depends on the transitions between them. A performance concerned only with the great fugue or the exposed soprano writing can obscure the function of the opening recitation and final withdrawal. The entire movement needs to preserve its clear verbal point of departure: the individual request, Libera me.
The Liturgical Text and the Human Voice
The words of the Messa da Requiem existed centuries before Verdi’s setting. The Roman Catholic Mass for the Dead brought together prayers for repose, expressions of praise and the extended medieval sequence Dies irae, describing the Day of Judgement. The Libera me belongs to the associated rites following the Mass. These different origins help explain the text’s changing ways of speaking: it describes, praises, confesses and petitions. Verdi works with liturgical texts inherited from that tradition. They are neither a libretto written for him nor a continuous collection of biblical passages. Within the predominantly Latin text, Kyrie eleison retains its Greek language.
One important change concerns grammatical person. In Requiem aeternam dona eis, the living ask for rest for “them”, the dead. The speaker of Ingemisco confesses personal guilt, while Libera me asks for deliverance in the first person. Those shifts are already present in the words. Verdi makes them audible through his allocation of voices: the tenor sings the confession of Ingemisco alone, and the soprano begins the final petition before the chorus takes it up. Reading the text and listening to the music reveal the same movement between communal prayer and individual apprehension.
The relationship between grammatical person and vocal group remains flexible. A chorus can also speak in the first person, as it does in Libera me. Conversely, the two women in Agnus Dei share a melody that asks for the rest of others. The four soloists have no fixed characters with separate stories. The bass who describes death’s astonishment in Mors stupebit also asks to be numbered among the blessed in Confutatis. His manner of singing changes with the words of each passage.
The connection with opera becomes clearer through this word–music relationship. In Recordare, sustained phrases let the two soloists continue the petition in turn. The pauses of Mors stupebit interrupt delivery, making arrested movement audible. At the opening of Libera me, repeated notes and freely measured declamation bring singing close to speech. These are particular ways of shaping language, related to the techniques Verdi had developed in the theatre.
That theatrical experience coexists with unaccompanied choral writing, fugues and the inherited order of the liturgical texts. The question of theatricality that accompanied the work’s reception can consequently be approached through specific musical choices. Dramatic contrasts explain how the words are brought to life; the liturgical sequence explains why one prayer follows another. Understanding the composition requires attention both to where its text comes from and to how the voices deliver it.
Returns, Recollection and Musical Unity
The seven movements differ considerably in length, pace and vocal forces. Two passages provide useful points of orientation across that variety: the opening Requiem aeternam and the eruption of the Dies irae. Verdi brings their music back later, when the words allow it to be heard again. These musical returns connect sections that might otherwise seem more independent.
Within the second movement’s long sequence, the Dies irae returns after Liber scriptus and again after Confutatis. Between its appearances, different voices make different appeals, from the question of Quid sum miser to the bass’s supplication. When the orchestral blows, rapid string movement and forceful choral delivery recur, the listener recognises particular music already heard. That recognition connects the new moment with the sequence’s opening and reintroduces the fear of judgement among the petitions.
In Libera me, the same return comes after a much greater distance. The Offertorio, Sanctus, Agnus Dei and Lux aeterna have intervened, with different melodies and vocal groups. The final movement’s text also refers to the day of wrath. Verdi uses this verbal connection to restore the familiar judgement music. Its return now joins the last movement to the second, establishing continuity across the composition’s larger divisions.
The Requiem aeternam creates a different link between beginning and ending. In the first movement, strings support the chorus. In Libera me, the related prayer is heard in another tonal area from chorus and soprano without instruments. Recognition and change can be heard together: the orchestra has withdrawn, and a high solo line joins the choral writing. The changed distribution leaves familiar material sounding more exposed.
Unity also depends on the allocation of forces. The chorus is silent throughout the Offertorio and Lux aeterna, and the full orchestra frequently gives way to a few instruments. The additional trumpets of Tuba mirum, the eight choral parts of the Sanctus and the two unaccompanied singers of Agnus Dei consequently have clearly different presences. If performance gives them similar weight and volume, the changes between movements become harder to hear. Preserving their differences helps the listener follow the work’s contrasts as well as its returns.
🪶 A Chapter in the Life of the Work
The Ending That Came First
On 17 November 1868, four days after Gioachino Rossini’s death, Verdi wrote to the publisher Tito Ricordi in Milan. He proposed bringing Italian composers together to write a memorial Mass, to be performed on the first anniversary at San Petronio in Bologna. Composers and performers would contribute their work without payment. Ricordi published the proposal, and preparations began for a public ceremony in Rossini’s honour.
A committee divided the sections among thirteen composers in all. Their separate contributions needed common specifications if they were to form a performable whole: the forces and order of movements were established, and each composer took responsibility for a portion of the text. Verdi reserved the last movement, Libera me. The composers could work separately, but hearing their music would require soloists, chorus and orchestra to assemble in the same city on the appointed day.
In August 1869, Verdi was working in Genoa. He asked Ricordi for manuscript paper to prepare his contribution and, on 20 August, announced that he would send the Libera me the following day. He added a practical instruction: if the ceremony did not take place, the score must be carefully preserved and returned to him. The music was ready, but its performance was still uncertain.
In Bologna, negotiations over the performing forces failed to produce the necessary arrangements. The theatre’s singers, chorus and orchestra had not been secured as required, and the anniversary was approaching. The composers had delivered their contributions, yet completed scores alone could not make the ceremony happen. The planned performance on 13 November was cancelled. Verdi’s final movement remained unheard alongside the other contributions.
Early in 1871, the manuscript prompted another exchange. The composer and conductor Alberto Mazzucato read it in Giulio Ricordi’s office and wrote enthusiastically to Verdi. His praise brought the possibility of a complete Requiem back into consideration. Replying on 4 February, Verdi acknowledged the temptation: the Libera me already contained material that could be expanded into a Requiem and a Dies irae. At the same time, he remarked on the abundance of existing Requiem Masses and made no commitment to write another. The idea was present, but a new composition had yet to follow.
Alessandro Manzoni’s death on 22 May 1873 gave that unfinished possibility a different direction. Verdi offered Milan a Mass that he would compose and conduct on the writer’s first anniversary. This time he would undertake the entire work himself. He returned to the earlier Libera me, revised it and connected it with the new movements he was composing. Music intended to conclude a collaborative memorial now became part of a work wholly his own.
On 22 May 1874, at San Marco in Milan, Verdi finally conducted the Libera me within a complete Mass. The soprano Teresa Stolz delivered its concluding petition after the six movements that preceded it. The audience heard a new composition for Manzoni; its final movement had begun its life five years earlier, for another anniversary whose musical plans had failed.
The collaborative Messa per Rossini had a much longer wait. Its first complete performance took place in Stuttgart in 1988, conducted by Helmuth Rilling. The Libera me could then be heard in its original position alongside the contributions of the other twelve composers. That performance finally gave the first project a public hearing, long after Verdi’s revised movement had become established as the conclusion of his own Requiem.
🎧 Listening Guide
On a first hearing, use the contrast between solo and choral voices, together with the returns of the judgement music, as your principal points of orientation. On a later hearing, focus on changing accompaniment and on the different presence a melody acquires when its vocal setting changes.
At the opening: follow the cellos before the chorus enters. Notice how much the sound changes when the voices are left unaccompanied in Te decet hymnus, and again when the tenor begins the Kyrie. These are three successive situations within one movement, each with a different density and manner of delivery.
In the Dies irae: retain the opening rhythm and the chorus’s way of pronouncing the words. In the Tuba mirum, listen for the distance between the trumpet groups. Then notice the sudden reduction of sound at Mors stupebit. The bass’s arrested delivery becomes more striking because it follows such a large concentration of brass and chorus.
Through the lyrical episodes: follow the handing over of phrases between the two female singers in the Recordare. In the Confutatis, hear how the bass changes delivery at voca me cum benedictis. Recognise the returning Dies irae before the Lacrymosa begins.
In the Offertorio and Sanctus: compare two ways of connecting voices. The former uses only the four soloists; in the latter, follow a short choral phrase as it passes between groups. The speed of the Sanctus becomes easier to understand if you listen to one new entry at a time.
In Agnus Dei and Lux aeterna: hear the unaccompanied shared melody of soprano and mezzo-soprano, then the choral response with instruments. In the following movement, notice the high strings beneath the opening mezzo-soprano and the change of accompaniment at the bass’s entry.
In Libera me: retain the succession of free recitation, returning Dies irae, unaccompanied Requiem aeternam and fugue. After the extended contrapuntal activity, follow the withdrawal towards a simpler statement of the appeal. The final quiet request belongs to the musical design and deserves the same attention as the loudest climax.
🎶 Further Listening
These performances offer different points of focus. Comparison becomes most revealing when the same passage is heard in each recording, particularly the Offertorio, the unaccompanied Agnus Dei or the transition from the fugue to the ending of Libera me.
- Carlo Maria Giulini — Philharmonia Orchestra and Philharmonia Chorus, with Elisabeth Schwarzkopf, Christa Ludwig, Nicolai Gedda and Nicolai Ghiaurov: broad phrasing allows the petitions to continue beyond their local climaxes. A useful performance for following the connection between solo voices in the Offertorio and the sustained intensity of quiet passages.
- Claudio Abbado — Berliner Philharmoniker, with Angela Gheorghiu, Daniela Barcellona, Roberto Alagna and Julian Konstantinov, 2001: the transparency of instrumental layers helps clarify the transitions between large choral writing and smaller ensembles. Listen to the movement of the strings in relation to the support given to the singers.
- Herbert von Karajan — Berliner Philharmoniker and Wiener Singverein, with Mirella Freni, Christa Ludwig, Carlo Cossutta and Nicolai Ghiaurov, 1972: the sustained orchestral sonority brings out affinities between widely separated climaxes. It offers a revealing comparison of how continuity can be maintained through changes of density and withdrawal.
- Riccardo Muti — Orchestra and Chorus of La Scala, with Cheryl Studer, Dolora Zajick, Luciano Pavarotti and Samuel Ramey, 1987: attention to articulation and rhythmic direction makes the relationship between language and music particularly clear. The Rex tremendae and returns of the Dies irae are rewarding places to follow the dramatic continuity.
- Georg Solti — Chicago Symphony Orchestra and Chicago Symphony Chorus, with Leontyne Price, Janet Baker, Veriano Luchetti and José van Dam, 1977: precise rhythmic attack and a distinct brass presence illuminate the construction of the larger sonic events. Comparison with the quieter sections reveals how strongly the impression of scale depends on the handling of contrast.
📚 Further Reading
- David Rosen — Verdi: Requiem: this dedicated volume in the Cambridge Music Handbooks series examines the genesis, individual movements, revisions and questions of genre. It is the most direct next step for readers wishing to connect details of the score with the work’s larger architecture.
- Giuseppe Verdi, edited by David Rosen — Messa da Requiem, critical edition: the orchestral score and critical commentary provide a basis for examining vocal writing, performing indications and earlier versions. The distinction between the 1874 Liber scriptus and its 1875 replacement is especially illuminating.
- Scott L. Balthazar, editor — The Cambridge Companion to Verdi: a broader historical and aesthetic setting for Verdi’s theatre, compositional methods and non-operatic music. It helps place the Requiem within his output without reducing it to the familiar idea of “opera in church”.
🔗 Related Works
- Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart — Requiem in D minor, K. 626: shared liturgical texts make direct comparison possible. The Confutatis is especially useful for hearing the difference between Mozart’s opposing choral groups and Verdi’s predominantly solo treatment.
- Johannes Brahms — A German Requiem, Op. 45: German biblical passages selected by the composer shift the emphasis towards consolation for those who mourn. The comparison shows how profoundly a memorial work changes when its textual foundation is different.
- Hector Berlioz — Grande Messe des morts, Op. 5: the spatial distribution of brass and the scale of the ensemble offer another approach to judgement music. Compare the organisation of distance with Verdi’s additional trumpets in the Tuba mirum.
- Ludwig van Beethoven — Missa solemnis, Op. 123: extended vocal and symphonic treatment of a liturgical text creates another balance between petition, praise and dramatic intensity. Its counterpoint offers a productive comparison with Verdi’s two large choral fugues.
- Gabriel Fauré — Requiem, Op. 48: a different selection and distribution of the texts reduces the dominance of judgement and gives repose another kind of emphasis. Comparing the forms and instrumentation reveals distinct musical experiences of consolation.
🎼 Closing Reflection
At the end of this immense composition, the human voice is still asking. It has drawn on the strength of a crowd, the precision of counterpoint and the exposure of unaccompanied prayer. The final quiet phrase can bring us close to an ordinary experience of mourning: the need to address someone, even when the music offers no certain answer. The time after the last note belongs to the person listening.
📖 Bibliography and Sources
The analysis was based on the orchestral score of David Rosen’s critical edition, with direct examination of vocal combinations, returning material, instrumentation and principal performing indications. Both musical examples come from page 184 and retain that edition’s bar numbering. The available introductory writings by Rosen and Norbert Bolín’s editorial foreword informed the account of the work’s creation. Recording identities were checked against label catalogues and the archives of the relevant musical organisations.
Score and critical edition
Verdi, Giuseppe. Messa da Requiem per l’anniversario della morte di Manzoni 22 maggio 1874. Edited by David Rosen. The Works of Giuseppe Verdi, Series III, Volume 1. University of Chicago Press and Ricordi, 1990. Orchestral score; digitised copy at IMSLP, no. 759892.
Genesis and editorial documentation
Rosen, David. Verdi: Requiem. Cambridge Music Handbooks. Cambridge University Press, 1995. Publisher’s available excerpt from the chapter on the work’s genesis, pp. 1–10.
Rosen, David. Introduction to the critical edition of the Messa da Requiem. University of Chicago Press and Ricordi, 1990. English introductory text made available by the publisher.
Bolín, Norbert. Foreword to Giuseppe Verdi’s Messa da Requiem. Vocal score by Paul Horn. Carus 27.303/04; foreword dated 2012. Historical account, references to correspondence and documentation of the first performance.
Ricordi. Giuseppe Verdi: Messa da Requiem — Critical Edition. Publisher’s account of David Rosen’s edition, the earlier versions of Libera me and Liber scriptus, and the orchestral forces.
McLean, Don. “Deliverance and Compositional Design in the ‘Libera me’ of Verdi’s Messa da Requiem.” In Explorations in Schenkerian Analysis, edited by David Beach and Su Yin Mak, pp. 241–282. Boydell & Brewer, 2016. The available publisher’s summary was consulted for the letter of 4 February 1871 and the relationship between the Libera me and preceding movements.
Recording documentation
Warner Classics. Catalogue entries for recordings of the Messa da Requiem conducted by Carlo Maria Giulini and Claudio Abbado.
Deutsche Grammophon. Verdi: Messa da Requiem — Herbert von Karajan. Catalogue entry and presentation of the 1972 recording with the Berliner Philharmoniker.
Riccardo Muti Music. Discographic presentation of the Messa da Requiem, including the 1987 La Scala performance.
Chicago Symphony Orchestra, Rosenthal Archives. Verdi’s Requiem, part 1, 3 October 2013. Documentation of Georg Solti’s recording on 1–2 June 1977.
