
Work Information
- Composer:
- George Frideric Handel (1685–1759)
- Title:
- Israel in Egypt, HWV 54
- Year of composition:
- 1738; the original opening part draws on the Funeral Anthem for Queen Caroline, HWV 264, composed in 1737
- First performance:
- 4 April 1739, King’s Theatre, Haymarket, London
- Genre:
- English biblical oratorio
- Musical period:
- Baroque
- Structure:
- Three parts in the original version: The Lamentation of the Israelites for the Death of Joseph — Exodus — Moses’ Song. The last two parts are frequently performed on their own.
- Duration:
- Approx. 120–140 minutes in the original three-part form; approx. 80–100 minutes without the opening lamentation, depending on performance choices and cuts
- Instrumentation:
- Soprano, alto, tenor and bass solo voices, including duets for two sopranos and two basses; four-part and double four-part mixed chorus; two oboes, two bassoons, two trumpets, three trombones, timpani, strings and basso continuo with organ and harpsichord. The Carus edition also provides for two flutes in a particular movement.
- Text:
- A compilation of biblical passages in English, principally from Exodus and the Psalms. The compiler of Exodus and Moses’ Song has not been identified with certainty; Charles Jennens’s involvement remains a scholarly hypothesis.
In Israel in Egypt, a chorus can begin with a sigh and soon fill the room with the energy of an entire community. Oppression, the plagues, the crossing of the sea and the thanksgiving that follows all pass through the same voices. What changes is the way those voices come together. At one moment they speak as one; at another, a new phrase begins before the preceding one has finished. Much of the drama emerges from these relationships. Handel gives the people of the biblical narrative a presence through the musical organisation of their many voices.
He composed the new music in the autumn of 1738, shortly after Saul, as English oratorio was assuming an increasingly important place in his theatrical career. His operatic experience remained audible in the shaping of a phrase, the immediacy of a contrast and the ability to redirect an audience’s attention. Here, however, the chorus occupies most of the dramatic space. Solo episodes are relatively few, and the biblical story unfolds without staging. The music must establish its own surroundings and convey its own action through a succession of sharply differentiated scenes.
Moses, Aaron and Pharaoh are named in the text, yet none has a sustained singing role equivalent to an operatic character. Even the enemy’s words belong to the narration: a solo voice makes his intentions audible before the music turns to their overthrow. The work is consequently concerned with communal memory as much as with the events themselves. Its chorus recounts what happened, gives time to the experience and eventually recasts it as thanksgiving. The distance between an event and the act of remembering it becomes part of the musical form.
The starting point of that journey depends on the version being performed. At the premiere, The Lamentation of the Israelites for the Death of Joseph, adapted from the funeral anthem for Queen Caroline, preceded Exodus and Moses’ Song. In the familiar two-part presentation, the lamentation is omitted: Exodus becomes Part I and Moses’ Song Part II. The original form begins with the memory of a benefactor; the two-part form brings us immediately into oppression. Although both reach the same conclusion, they give the listener different experiences of the community before its deliverance.
The order in which Handel composed the new sections adds another perspective. He wrote Moses’ Song first, then Exodus. Their eventual position in the oratorio therefore reverses the sequence of their creation. In performance, their relationship is nevertheless clear. Exodus moves from one event to the next; Moses’ Song returns to those events and gives them room within a hymn of praise. Extended choral writing allows the music to dwell on what the narrative has already told us.
The predominance of the chorus brings remarkable flexibility. The voices can express suffering in restrained phrases, unfold long contrapuntal lines or converge in a sudden declaration. Around them, the orchestra sometimes pursues its own activity and sometimes reinforces their articulation. The force of the work depends on a clear entrance or a withdrawal of accompaniment as much as on a grand climax. As the community’s memories change, so does the way it speaks.
Movements / Structure
The following outline follows the original three-part form. The numbering of individual movements varies between editions, since some connected choral sequences are divided into several separate numbers. Their opening words provide a reliable point of reference when the numbering in a score differs from the track list of a recording.
| Part | Subject | Musical and dramatic function |
|---|---|---|
| I — The Lamentation of the Israelites for the Death of Joseph | Mourning for Joseph, remembrance of his justice and generosity, consolation | An orchestral introduction followed by a continuous choral sequence; the community first appears through its grief |
| II — Exodus | A new king, enslavement, the sending of Moses, selected plagues, departure and the crossing of the sea | Brief recitatives, one alto aria and predominantly choral movements; the narrative advances through contrasting rhythms, colours and textures |
| III — Moses’ Song | Thanksgiving after deliverance, recollection of the destruction of the pursuers, anticipation of a secure home | An extended hymn comprising choruses, arias and duets; the completed crossing becomes a shared affirmation and act of praise |
The individual movements explore a succession of tonal regions. G minor in the opening lamentation, C minor in the Israelites’ sighing and C major in the great proclamations of Moses’ Song are important landmarks. Between them lie many changes of colour and emphasis, as each episode establishes its own harmonic surroundings. A single key designation cannot adequately describe this oratorio in the way it might identify a sonata or concerto.
Musical Analysis
Part I — Mourning and the Memory of Joseph
Before the first word is sung, the short orchestral Symphony has established the terms of the lament. Its Largo assai marking and G minor give weight to the rests, dotted rhythms and slow harmonic movement. The phrases proceed with a solemnity that seems to gather the voices around a loss before allowing them to speak. The ceremonial character grows out of the relationship between the measured pace and the firmness of the articulation. Even when movement is limited, the music retains its gravity.
In The sons of Israel do mourn, restrained choral phrases enter against instrumental lines with greater internal activity. Grief becomes audible on two levels: the singers sustain the words while the accompaniment continues to move around them. As imitative entries develop, the same thought passes from one voice to another. Each fresh beginning can be followed by ear, revealing how a shared expression is sustained through separate breaths.
Here polyphony allows mourning to expand without becoming static. One phrase continues while another begins, so that the end of a melodic line does not immediately end the experience it conveys. Sorrow persists in the continuity of the ensemble. When the singers move towards a more unified delivery, attention settles again on the words themselves. This change can be heard without following the score: the texture gathers what had previously been distributed among several voices.
The declaration How is the mighty fall’n returns between the different sections. Each recurrence restores the sense of loss after the music has turned towards the deeds of the person being mourned. He put on righteousness and He deliver’d the poor recall justice and protection of the vulnerable. Joseph acquires a presence through what he gave to others; his memory takes shape in the voices of those who remain. The returning lament helps orient the sequence, and the remembrance of his generosity makes his absence more specific.
The connections between these choral movements keep the form close to the English anthem, a sacred choral composition that brings together contrasting musical sections on a biblical text. The boundaries between numbers do not always have the independence of an operatic aria. A section may alter its rhythmic motion, follow chordal writing with imitation or lead closely into the next, leaving the impression of a thought still being developed. That continuity matters in listening. The part traces a gradual working through of grief, with changes of perspective and moments of return.
In Their bodies are buried in peace, repose is conveyed through the easing of movement and the sustained weight of the vocal phrases. The text enables the music to move beyond the immediate announcement of death and dwell on the peace of those who have died. Later sections turn towards the remembrance of the righteous and the promise of a glorious kingdom. Consolation emerges gradually among phrases that still carry the solemnity of mourning. It is felt through a change in musical breathing and harmonic stability, rather than as an abrupt departure from sorrow.
The part’s origin in Queen Caroline’s funeral anthem accounts for its ceremonial manner. Its new position in the oratorio creates an additional relationship: the remembrance of Joseph comes before the account of a king who did not know him. The community first recalls someone who protected it, then confronts a power disconnected from that memory. In the three-part form, the listener reaches enslavement having already heard what protection meant. Without this opening, oppression becomes the first human condition the work presents.
Part II — Exodus: From Sighing to Movement
With Now there arose a new king, the tenor establishes the changed circumstances in the spare language of recitative. Basso continuo, the harmonic foundation combining a bass line with the realisation of chords, allows the words to move directly forward. The music passes quickly from the change of ruler to the experience of those who suffer under him. The brevity of this narration makes the extended expression of their distress all the more striking.
In And the children of Israel sigh’d, the Largo marking, C minor and 6/4 metre create broad phrases in which relief seems continually postponed. The solo alto introduces the sorrow, and the chorus takes it up on a larger scale. Successive entries and harmonic friction keep the word of sighing alive as an enduring human condition. Where the recitative supplied its information swiftly, the choral music remains: the time needed to tell the story gives way to the time spent living through its ordeal.
Then sent he Moses turns the music towards action again. The sending of Moses introduces intervention, and in They loathed to drink of the river the water, now changed to blood, becomes an object of revulsion. Persistent treatment of the words gives the choral delivery a character distinct from the preceding lament. The narrative has changed its focus to the plagues afflicting Egypt. The response extends beyond an external description, because the musical articulation itself makes the disgust tangible.
The aria Their land brought forth frogs suddenly reduces the performing forces. The alto, two violin lines and continuo give the scene a more agile character. In 3/4, marked Andante, the violins move through leaps, brief interruptions and pointed restarts. The suggestion of hopping comes from the way the figure begins, breaks off and reappears elsewhere in the phrase. Both instrumental lines sustain this activity even as the singer stretches out the words, allowing the image of the frogs to surround the vocal account.
That lightness has a purpose within the sequence of plagues. A change in scale and motion gives the image an identity of its own, while the aria offers the ear some distance from the density of the chorus. When the larger ensemble returns, its expansion becomes immediately perceptible. The contrast prepares the next scene through the experience of sound, before its words have fully established the new subject.
In He spake the word, clear choral statements stand above an orchestra in almost continuous activity. Rapid string figures evoke the spreading insects through small notes that succeed and intertwine with one another. The impression of proliferation comes from this activity beneath and around the singers. The chorus provides the verbal point of reference; the accompaniment makes the surrounding space seem full of movement that cannot easily be contained within a single direction.
The next plague changes the relationship between voices and orchestra once more. In He gave them hailstones for rain, choral articulation acquires a percussive weight, while strings, brass and timpani enlarge the impact. Repeated phrases suggest successive blows. On the words describing fire, rapid movement adds another kind of energy: the music combines the force of a strike with the speed of something spreading. The climax grows from the conjunction of these different activities.
Then the momentum stops. He sent a thick darkness unfolds at Largo, with sustained notes and slow harmonic changes burdened by chromatic inflections. After the hailstorm’s motion, the duration of a chord seems almost physically heavy. The voices remain inside the harmony, and the phrase struggles to recover its former clear direction. Darkness can be heard as a loss of orientation. Change continues, yet it offers little sense that time is opening out ahead.
Musical depiction has relinquished speed here. Slow harmonic movement is enough to alter the listener’s experience, holding attention within a dense and weighty sound. The position of this scene between the hailstorm and the striking of the firstborn gives the waiting a particular dramatic force. Stillness prepares a new and more final violence.
Marked A tempo giusto e staccato, He smote all the firstborn of Egypt restores a measured pulse and abrupt articulation. Detached instrumental attacks and imitative choral entries make the same blow recur through the ensemble. Each new voice adds its statement, while the separated movement resists the impression of an unbroken, flowing line. The narrative has reached an irreversible event, and the sound gives it sharply defined edges.
From this point, But as for his people changes the human perspective. The image of a flock being led to safety brings a gentler tread, more supple phrases and a different instrumental colour. The flutes provided in this movement by the Carus edition contribute to that change of sound. Relief comes through the music’s renewed ability to proceed continuously, free from the successive assaults of the preceding scenes. Having remained for some time with destruction, the work now gives room to those who are protected.
Egypt was glad when they departed brings the movement of departure. The Red Sea sequence must then connect an act of command with two entirely different outcomes. He rebuked the Red Sea has a stern character, as though the music were gathering its strength before opening a passage. In He led them through the deep, successive contrapuntal entries carry the journey from one voice to another. The writing creates a sense of organised passage: each line advances through a common space while the others keep the movement alive.
In But the waters overwhelmed their enemies, the movement changes direction and weight. Rapid instrumental and vocal responses concentrate the destruction of the pursuers. Within the same sequence, the sea has become a passage for one people and an engulfing force for another. The music connects its two functions, completing the narrative without requiring a staged representation of the miracle.
And Israel saw that great work and And believed the Lord transfer attention from what happens to the people who recognise its significance. The community responds to its deliverance, and choral development allows that response to expand. Exodus has reached the point at which the story can change its mode of expression. The next part will take up the same events within a hymn.
Part III — Moses’ Song: The Story Becomes a Hymn
Moses’ Song follows the fifteenth chapter of Exodus. The crossing has already taken place, and the narrative returns to it from the position of those who have been saved. Its words recall the sea, the pursuit and the destruction of the enemy, then gradually turn towards a secure home for the people and the enduring reign of God. The music must hold recollection and anticipation together. The length of the part allows both to develop within a thanksgiving that contains many shades of expression.
Moses and the children of Israel and I will sing unto the Lord begin with the assurance of a public proclamation. C major, the duple framework and the two choirs provide a firm point of orientation. The music retains the strength of a collective statement while allowing the words of triumph to develop in more active lines. The difference can be heard between a passage sung together and one in which the voices begin to elaborate the same idea independently. Joy acquires internal movement without losing its coherence.
The duet The Lord is my strength brings that joy into a more intimate setting. Two sopranos exchange and connect phrases in a closely related vocal colour, preserving the personal immediacy of the biblical words. One voice can continue where the other takes breath, and their meeting has a different character from the shared delivery of a full chorus. Within the hymn’s broad architecture, this smaller relationship offers closeness. Thanksgiving becomes something that two people can share with one another.
The return of the chorus in He is my God restores weight and solemnity. In And I will exalt Him, imitative movement extends the act of praise. The same phrase continues to appear while earlier entries are still sounding. The change of texture carries the music from concentrated recognition towards an active, sustained offering of praise. Counterpoint becomes a means of prolonging the words, as each voice receives them and carries them onward.
In The Lord is a man of war, two basses decisively change the colour. D major, the Andante allegro marking and an energetic instrumental introduction articulate the image of strength. The low voices exchange material and join in shared phrases, combining the weight of their sound with melodic agility. As the text turns to Pharaoh’s chariots and army, the music preserves the energy of narration within the established setting of thanksgiving. The smaller ensemble gives the words a particular character before the chorus resumes the larger perspective.
With The depths have covered them, the hymn returns to the engulfing water. The direction of the phrases and changes of density keep the destruction present within the act of remembrance. In Thy right hand, O Lord, power is expressed through successive choral entries and the interweaving of lines. The connected sections that follow change their delivery rapidly, bringing solemnity, momentum and abrupt compression into the praise. Musical variety follows the shifting emphasis of the text and keeps the extended hymn in continual development.
In And with the blast of thy nostrils, the active accompaniment gives the natural world a musical presence once again. The reference to wind and water prepares the confrontation between the next two arias. In The enemy said, the tenor announces the intention to pursue and plunder through short verbal units, repetitions and vigorous violin writing. The haste of the words can be heard as confidence: the enemy’s plans follow one another with little time for hesitation.
The soprano aria Thou didst blow with the wind turns to the answer. A change of vocal colour and phrasing immediately distinguishes the new perspective, while the accompaniment maintains the movement required by the reference to wind. The plan so energetically laid out is overturned. Together, the arias create a compressed drama within the hymn, different voices conveying human intention and the force that defeats it. The tenor and soprano occupy these momentary positions within the account without becoming sustained operatic characters.
The question Who is like unto Thee gathers the ensemble into a solemn statement again. After the activity of the arias, its words are allowed to stand. The earth swallowed them compresses the return to action before the duet Thou in thy mercy turns towards the guidance of the people. Alto and tenor connect their phrases in a gentler relationship. The affinity with the pastoral episode in Exodus is chiefly one of meaning: protection reappears among the descriptions of power, allowing the hymn to look towards the future.
The people shall hear extends the account to the nations learning of what has happened. The music differentiates its movement around references to fear and stillness, giving the news consequences beyond those who experienced the crossing. The chorus allows these responses to develop before Thou shalt bring them in draws attention away from the surrounding nations and back to the Israelites’ own expectation.
Here the alto, A major and 3/8 metre offer one of the hymn’s gentlest moments of repose. The Largo e mezzo piano marking and connected violin figures let the phrase unfold softly. The promise of a secure dwelling has time of its own: after allowing the ordeal such breadth, the music can remain with what is still hoped for. The change of tonal region helps suggest another space, removed from the pressure of pursuit. The serenity of this passage makes the final choral return more immediately felt.
The Lord shall reign for ever and ever restores the public declaration, and brief recitatives recalling the crossing and introducing Miriam lead to Sing ye to the Lord. C major and the material of the opening thanksgiving provide a recognisable frame for the close. The soprano introduces the invitation, and the chorus takes it up on a broader scale. The relationship between the opening I will sing and the final Sing ye is significant: the intention to praise has become an invitation to others. After the arias, duets and changes of choral texture, the return carries the experience of everything that has intervened. The shared sound now holds the memory of the journey that brought it here.
The Double Chorus as Musical Architecture
A double chorus gives Handel two complete groups of sopranos, altos, tenors and basses. This resource concerns the relationships between voices as much as the size of the sound. The groups can exchange phrases, develop eight independent lines or bring corresponding voices together in a more compact texture. The ear distinguishes these possibilities through the way an idea begins and continues. Sometimes an answer follows a completed statement; sometimes it arrives while that statement is still unfolding.
In antiphonal exchange, succession offers clarity. A phrase passes from the first group to the second, shifting its position within the ensemble. In contrapuntal overlap, the same idea acquires greater internal movement because its entries are at different stages of development. A listener recognises the beginning of a new line while others are already continuing. When the voices converge in a shared chordal delivery, their dispersed activity gathers into a single emphasis. A word arrives with the weight of the whole ensemble behind it.
These changes explain how the chorus can convey such different experiences. Sighing needs duration and the postponement of relief; a command needs pointed articulation; praise needs room for sustained expansion. The compositional techniques remain available throughout, but their place in the narrative and their relationship to the words change their effect. Within what appears to be one continuing protagonist, the double chorus opens a rich field of expressive possibilities.
Performance needs to keep these relationships audible. Clear consonants, coordinated beginnings and balance among the inner voices help the imitative entries remain distinct in dense passages. The sound has greater force when the listener can hear how it is being formed. A gentler phrase, meanwhile, needs enough continuity to preserve its direction. Tempo, articulation and the acoustics of the room all affect the relationship between detail and the larger impression.
The orchestra helps shape that balance. Strings can maintain rapid, independent motion around a comparatively steady choral statement, while woodwind changes the colour or strengthens particular lines. Brass and timpani enlarge the weight of certain climaxes. Continuo sustains the harmonic foundation with different degrees of presence in recitatives, arias and choruses. The accompaniment participates in the dramatic perspective, as becomes especially clear when the insects’ ceaseless activity yields to the slow harmonies of darkness.
Writing for two choirs does not, by itself, determine the number of singers. A smaller ensemble may bring out the exchanges and eight-part lines clearly, while larger forces give a different weight to the shared declarations. Historical versions, editions and continuo indications also require attention, since they do not all present precisely the same performing conditions. The work accommodates different scales of sound, provided the chosen approach preserves the relationships written into the music.
Musical Depiction and the Reworking of Existing Music
The plagues supply the work’s most readily identifiable images. Hopping frogs, the dispersed activity of insects, the blows of hail and the slowness of darkness each correspond to a different organisation of sound. Musical depiction involves the instruments, choral articulation and harmony. It can arise from a small violin figure, from many voices meeting on one word or from a chord that lasts longer than the preceding flow has led us to expect.
In the vocal writing, melismas are particularly significant: a single syllable extends across several notes. The word acquires duration and movement as its articulation becomes part of the melody. Elsewhere, a brief, shared delivery concentrates attention on a blow or command. Such alternation changes the relationship between words that communicate an event and music that allows us to remain with its image.
The force of individual scenes also depends on their position. Hail and darkness are heard differently when understood as successive transformations of the same musical time. The gentle leading of the flock restores a human focus after the scenes of destruction. The narrative selects and combines biblical passages rather than setting all ten plagues consecutively. Its contrasts serve that selection: each scene adds a new condition to the passage from enslavement to deliverance.
Alongside vivid depiction, Handel works with music that has already existed in other compositions. The transfer of the funeral anthem to Part I is the most evident example. Research has also identified borrowings from other composers, including Dionigi Erba’s Magnificat. Existing material enters a new arrangement of words, voices and instruments. Its origins help explain how the work was made; analysis also needs to follow what happens when that material is placed in a different relationship with what precedes and follows it.
In the lamentation, the change of function is especially clear. Music for a royal funeral enters the story of Joseph, and the remembrance of a benefactor becomes connected with later oppression. The musical text retains its ceremonial gravity, but the narrative around it has altered. Listening now includes the anticipation of Exodus, even while the community remains for a time within mourning.
The coherence of the oratorio is therefore shaped in part by the new relationships between its materials. Individual episodes can retain their own identity while their succession connects contrasting movements and different vocal groupings. A change of text, the distribution of performing forces and a movement’s position alter what we hear within it. At the end, the return of the thanksgiving music provides another connection that can be recognised by ear, in a work that has travelled through so many different images.
🪶 A Chapter in the Life of the Work
A Chorus on a Cylinder
When Israel in Egypt was first heard in London on 4 April 1739, the prominence of its chorus did not guarantee acceptance. The music asked the audience at the King’s Theatre to remain for long stretches within a communal expression, with relatively few solo interludes. In subsequent performances, Handel altered the form, adding arias and shortening choral movements. The work had already begun to change as it sought a place before its listeners.
Over time, that relationship shifted. The choral culture of the nineteenth century gave Israel in Egypt a different public life, in concerts and festivals employing very large forces. Performances could concentrate their weight on the very feature that had complicated its early reception: the extent and variety of the shared voice. Scale changed, along with acoustics and audience expectations. Handel’s music moved from the London theatre into a later tradition of public choral gatherings.
On 29 June 1888, within that tradition, the work was performed at the Crystal Palace under August Manns. There George Gouraud, Thomas Edison’s representative, attempted to capture part of its sound with a phonograph. The concert belonged to the world of massed choral performance; the recording opened the possibility that something of it might be heard after the singers and audience had gone. A small machine was attempting to preserve a trace of music that had acquired an imposing public scale.
The excerpt was recorded on a paraffin cylinder. A note accompanying it describes four thousand voices and a distance of more than one hundred yards between them and the phonograph. These figures belong to the historical documentation; the recording alone cannot establish an exact count of performers. The note nevertheless brings two very different scales into view: the multitude singing and the small physical object on which an impression of their combined sound was being made.
In the score, the great chorus still consists of separate musical lines. For the phonograph, the performance arrives as sound from a particular distance, subject to the limits of the recording process. That difference remains palpable in the surviving excerpt. The music emerges through noise and offers little of the transparency needed for a detailed judgement of vocal balance. Yet its presence changes our relationship to that concert. Beside the date and the names, something of the performance can still be heard. Written information has acquired an audible continuation.
The cylinder is now preserved at the Thomas Edison National Historical Park under catalogue number E-2440-20, and the excerpt is available in the institution’s digital presentation of early recordings. It belongs among the very early surviving traces of recorded music. Its significance becomes particularly tangible when we consider the journey of this specific work: an eighteenth-century composition, performed in the nineteenth, reaches us through an object that retained part of an actual concert moment.
Much remains beyond the recording’s reach. The clarity of inner parts, subtle changes of articulation and relationships between the two choirs cannot be recovered with the ease of a modern recording. That incompleteness limits what can be concluded about the performance, while making the value of its survival more apparent. Some of the sound of that day remained available, although the people who produced it now belong to a distant past.
Returning from the cylinder to a present-day performance gives choral clarity an additional significance. We can distinguish the voice that begins, the answer that follows and the moment when the lines meet. The distant document preserves something of the multitude’s presence; hearing the music clearly again brings us closer to the separate breaths from which it is formed. Handel’s chorus regains its internal distances, and the shared sound becomes once more a meeting of distinct voices.
🎧 Listening Guide
Knowing which version is being performed gives a first hearing a clearer starting point. If the lamentation for Joseph is included, the music begins with the memory of a loss. If the opening words are Now there arose a new king, the listener enters Exodus directly. This distinction explains the substantial differences in duration between performances and changes the surroundings of the Israelites’ first sigh. In the three-part form, the returns of How is the mighty fall’n provide a useful point of reference within the lamentation’s continuous choral sequence.
In Exodus, the broad pace of And the children of Israel sigh’d offers the first strong aural landmark. Vocal entries prolong the experience of suffering before the account changes direction. The frog aria introduces a very different movement: the violins’ small leaps and fresh starts remain audible around the alto’s line. In He spake the word, following the strings beneath the choral statements reveals the activity that creates the image of the insects.
The succession of hail and darkness is one of the clearest demonstrations of the dramatic use of time. After the impacts and rapid motion, the music remains with slow harmonic changes. The shift can be recognised even without knowing the words: the phrase’s very ability to move forward has altered. The gentle guidance of But as for his people then supplies another direction, with greater continuity and a sense of relief.
At the sea, command, passage and the engulfing of the enemies create three different movements within a single narrative sequence. Distinguishing them helps clarify the shift from physical action to the community’s response at the end of Exodus. By the time Moses’ Song begins, the music has reached the perspective of remembrance and thanksgiving.
The duets in the hymn offer readily audible changes of vocal colour. The two sopranos in The Lord is my strength, the two basses in The Lord is a man of war, and alto and tenor in Thou in thy mercy establish different relationships between their phrases. On a later hearing, the transitions from these smaller groups to the double chorus can provide the principal thread: the beginning of each new entry, the overlap of lines and their gathering into a shared statement. The return of the opening thanksgiving music supplies the final recognisable landmark, after the ear has passed through so many different forms of the same communal expression.
🎶 Further Listening
- Andrew Parrott — Taverner Choir & Players. The original three-part form allows the lamentation to be heard as the beginning of the whole story, before enslavement and deliverance. This interpretation provides a useful setting for following the choral lines and understanding how the final thanksgiving acquires a different weight when the memory of Joseph has preceded it.
- Stephen Cleobury — Choir of King’s College, Cambridge / Brandenburg Consort. English choral tradition meets a period-instrument ensemble, inviting attention to the relationship between sustained vocal phrasing and instrumental articulation. The colour of the upper choral voices offers a particular focus in the polyphonic movements, where a melodic line needs to remain distinct within the ensemble.
- Julian Wachner — The Choir of Trinity Wall Street / Trinity Baroque Orchestra. This release presents the 1756 revision and includes the original opening part of 1739 separately. Comparing the different beginnings illuminates the work’s performing history: a changed opening alters what the listener has already experienced on reaching Exodus. The sequence of the release matters, since the original lamentation is presented separately.
📚 Further Reading
- Annette Landgraf — Critical edition of Israel in Egypt, Hallische Händel-Ausgabe, Series I, Volume 14, Bärenreiter. A fundamental editorial starting point for studying the historical versions of the work. The available preface and contents help distinguish the changes made for the performances of 1739 from the more extensive revisions of 1756–1757, preventing those forms from being conflated in a general account.
- Clifford Bartlett — Edition of Israel in Egypt, Carus 55.264 and 55.054. Combining the separately published first part with the score of Exodus and Moses’ Song makes it possible to follow the original three-part journey. The preface also addresses the reuse of music and questions of performing forces, both central to understanding the work and its sound.
- Donald Burrows — Handel, second edition, Oxford University Press, 2012. This biographical and musical survey provides a wider setting for the development from Italian opera towards English oratorio. It helps place Handel’s choices within the continuity of his theatrical activity and his changing relationship with audiences.
- Ruth Smith — Handel’s Oratorios and Eighteenth-Century Thought, Cambridge University Press, 1995. A study of the intellectual and social surroundings of the oratorios. It provides context for contemporary interest in biblical history and communal identity, without requiring a single political interpretation of Israel in Egypt.
🔗 Related Works
- George Frideric Handel — Saul, HWV 53: Composed close to Israel in Egypt, this oratorio establishes a different balance between individual characters, chorus and orchestra. The comparison brings the distinctive dramaturgy of Israel in Egypt into focus.
- George Frideric Handel — Messiah, HWV 56: The compilation of biblical texts and the absence of a conventional sequence of operatic roles provide a meaningful parallel. The relationship between narration, reflection and praise is nevertheless different.
- Johann Sebastian Bach — St Matthew Passion, BWV 244: Two vocal and instrumental ensembles provide a basis for comparing the use of double chorus. The Evangelist’s narrative function and the roles assigned to individual characters establish a different relationship between the individual and the community.
- Joseph Haydn — The Creation, Hob. XXI:2: Musical depiction of the natural world and large choral proclamations offer a later perspective on the relationship between description and hymn.
- Felix Mendelssohn — Elijah, Op. 70: Biblical narrative meets the orchestral and choral language of the nineteenth century. The work offers a way to explore the development of oratorio during an age of vigorous public choral activity.
🎼 Closing Reflection
A voice can begin alone and find its continuation in others. In Israel in Egypt, something of the sigh seems to remain within the thanksgiving, a memory given room in the shared sound. The voices sing together now, carrying the journey that brought them to this point.
📖 Bibliography & Sources
The distinction between the original three-part form and later versions draws on the prefaces to the Landgraf and Bartlett editions. Musical analysis follows the Carus score of Exodus and Moses’ Song, together with the available sample vocal score and piano reduction of the opening lamentation. Observations on texture, articulation and dramatic function arise from reading these musical texts. The account of the 1888 recording uses the Thomas Edison National Historical Park’s documentation of the surviving cylinder.
Scores and Critical Editions
George Frideric Handel, Israel in Egypt, HWV 54, Parts II–III. Edited by Clifford Bartlett. Carus 55.054, 2008. Full score, English preface and contents.
George Frideric Handel, Israel in Egypt, Part I / The Ways of Zion do Mourn, HWV 264. Edited by Clifford Bartlett; piano reduction by Paul Horn. Carus 55.264/03. Available vocal-score sample and abridged preface.
George Frideric Handel, Israel in Egypt: The Versions of the 1739 and 1756–7 Performances. Hallische Händel-Ausgabe, Series I, Volume 14, edited by Annette Landgraf. Bärenreiter. The preface and contents consulted are those of the corresponding vocal score, BA 4063a, with piano reduction by Andreas Köhs; preface dated January 2004.
Primary Historical Evidence
Thomas Edison National Historical Park, Handel Festival: Israel in Egypt — excerpt. Paraffin cylinder, E-2440-20. Recorded by George Gouraud; conducted by August Manns. Crystal Palace, London, 29 June 1888. Note accompanying the cylinder and the institution’s digital presentation of the recording.
Dates in the autograph and information from historical librettos are documented through the critical prefaces of the editions listed above.
Digital Resources and Discographic Documentation
Carus-Verlag: work descriptions and digital samples of editions 55.054 and 55.264/03.
Bärenreiter: description of edition BA 4063 and the available preface to BA 4063a.
National Park Service, Very Early Recorded Sound: institutional documentation of the 1888 cylinder.
Taverner: Handel: Israel in Egypt, discographic entry for Andrew Parrott / Taverner Choir & Players. Recorded in 1989; released by EMI Reflexe in 1990.
Michael Chance: discographic entry for Stephen Cleobury / Choir of King’s College, Cambridge / Brandenburg Consort. Recorded at King’s College Chapel in July 1995.
Musica Omnia: George Frideric Handel: Israel in Egypt, Julian Wachner / The Choir of Trinity Wall Street / Trinity Baroque Orchestra, MO0404. Recorded in November 2010; released in 2012. Release information and the arrangement of its contents were consulted.