![]() |
| In Rachmaninoff’s youthful Prelude, the opening call returns with the weight of a great piano climax. Moscow in the distance and the suggestion of bells connect the scene with the work’s resonant sound world. |
Work Information
- Composer:
- Sergei Rachmaninoff (1873–1943)
- Title:
- Prelude in C-sharp minor, Op. 3 No. 2, from Morceaux de fantaisie
- Year of composition:
- 1892
- First performance:
- 26 September / 8 October 1892, Moscow Electrical Exhibition; the composer at the piano (Julian / Gregorian calendar)
- Genre:
- Prelude for solo piano
- Musical period:
- Romanticism — the Russian tradition of the late nineteenth century
- Structure:
- A continuous work in ternary form, A–B–A′, followed by a coda
- Duration:
- approx. 3–5 minutes
- Instrumentation:
- Solo piano
- Dedication:
- Anton Arensky, dedicatee of the complete Op. 3 collection
- First publication:
- Moscow: A. Gutheil, 1893
Rachmaninoff’s Prelude in C-sharp minor was one of the short piano pieces that brought the young composer an audience far beyond Russia. Written in 1892, as he completed his composition studies at the Moscow Conservatory, it unfolds a striking drama within a few minutes. Three imposing notes are answered almost in a whisper; restless motion gathers force; and the opening returns on a vastly expanded scale. The entire journey can be followed by ear, even without a score.
The Prelude is the second of five Morceaux de fantaisie, Op. 3, dedicated to Rachmaninoff’s composition teacher, Anton Arensky. It stands between the Élégie and the Mélodie. Where those neighbouring pieces suggest a more directly singing voice, the Prelude makes its presence felt through octaves and startling contrasts of dynamics. Its independent concert life became so extensive that its original place in the five-piece collection is easily forgotten.
Here, a “prelude” is not an introduction to something else but a complete piece in its own right. Its modest length conceals a considerable range of piano sound: bare octaves and widely spaced, quiet chords eventually grow into a dense, almost orchestral texture.
The opening call, and especially its later return, may suggest the sound of bells. Yet the original publication bears only the title Prélude, with no stated narrative programme. What matters first is the musical process: how a tiny motif remains recognisable while everything around it changes.
Movements / Structure
The Prelude is played without a break. Its ternary design, A–B–A′, places the slow, chordal opening against the continuous triplet motion of the Agitato. The return does more than repeat the beginning: it transforms that material into the climax, before a short, quiet coda. In the measure references below, the first two notes are treated as a pickup, following the numbering of the Henle critical edition.
| Region | Marking and measures | Structural role |
|---|---|---|
| A — Opening statement | Lento, pickup and mm. 1–13 | The descending motto interacts with short chordal phrases, within the prevailing C-sharp minor tonality. |
| B — Motion and accumulation | Agitato, mm. 14–42 | A melody emerges through triplet figuration, leading to a forceful descent in chords. |
| A′ — Transformed return | Mm. 43–54; Tempo primo from m. 45 | The opening notes reappear, followed by the theme expanded across four staves at a powerful dynamic level. |
| Coda — Withdrawal | Mm. 55–61 | Changing chords over the low C-sharp lead to a quiet ending in the original key. |
These are stages of one continuous musical argument, not separate movements. The arrival at mm. 43–44 is especially important: the returning opening motif both completes the accumulation of the Agitato and announces the return of the Lento.
Musical Analysis
Lento — The call and the quiet reply
Just three notes establish the work’s identity: A–G-sharp–C-sharp, played in octaves at fortissimo. The first movement is small, a semitone from A to G-sharp; the next is a much wider descent to C-sharp. That final note is held, allowing the sound to spread before the chordal answer begins. The opening’s impact depends not only on the volume of the notes but also on the time they are given to resonate.
In C-sharp minor, the notes form scale degrees six, five and one. The line clearly moves towards the tonic, yet the bare octaves contain no chordal third to establish a major or minor quality on their own. That becomes clearer in the harmonies of the reply. The sense of key therefore emerges through the relationship between the call and what follows it, rather than being fully stated at the first attack.
The reply arrives at the opposite dynamic extreme: ppp, extremely softly. Both hands form chords, while the low notes continue to lend weight to the phrase. Rests distinguish one attack from another and leave room for resonance. From the outset, the music sets the insistent, economical motto against more mobile chordal phrases that answer it.
![]() |
| Example 1 — Lento, pickup and mm. 1–3: the opening octave motto and its chordal reply at ppp. Complete piano texture. Source: A. Gutheil / Breitkopf & Härtel, undated later impression, plate A. 6516 G., p. 2; Sibley Music Library, University of Rochester, M25.R119 op.3. Measure numbering follows Henle, treating the first two notes as a pickup. |
Repetition does not mean that the harmony stands still. The chords climb, the inner voices change chromatically, and the dynamics grow around mm. 6–7. Of particular importance is the minor dominant, G-sharp minor: its B natural lessens the strong pull towards the tonic that a major dominant would normally create. Even as the phrase turns back towards C-sharp, its dark, suspended quality remains.
Near the end of the Lento, the dynamics and register recede. The opening motto is already familiar, but this quiet close does not bring the musical argument to an end. The remaining melodic movement prepares a continuation of a very different kind.
Agitato — A melody within the triplets
At m. 14, the music acquires a new sense of flow. Separate chords give way to continuous eighth-note triplets: each quarter-note beat is divided into three equal notes. The metre remains 4/4. What changes is the density of motion and the restless character of the Agitato.
In the right hand, the triplets do more than carry a stream of fast notes. Their upper notes trace a melody while the others fill in the harmony. At the start, the line descends E–D-sharp–D-natural–C-sharp. The D natural, a chromatic note outside the key signature, sharpens the approach to C-sharp. Hearing those upper notes as a connected line reveals a melody that moves more slowly than the figuration surrounding it.
The left hand initially supports the phrase in longer values in the bass. With each recurrence, the melody and bass shift position, the figures rise, and the phrases extend. Familiar material preserves continuity, even as the expanding register makes it increasingly difficult for the music to remain at the same level of intensity. C-sharp minor continues to be the principal tonal point of reference.
From m. 27, the writing rises into a higher register and prepares a decisive change. In the second half of m. 35, flowing triplets give way to dense chords in both hands. With the fff marking and a succession of descending chords, the emphasis moves away from the melody heard within the earlier figuration and towards the force of the attacks themselves.
The chordal descent continues through m. 42, moving towards the lower keyboard without losing the accumulated intensity. When the opening three notes return, they no longer emerge from the relative stillness of the beginning. They arrive as the outcome of this sustained, increasingly weighty movement.
The return — The same idea on a larger scale
At mm. 43–44 the opening descending motif is immediately recognisable, now embedded in powerful, widely spaced sonorities. The Agitato has not erased its memory; it has prepared a new way of hearing it. What first sounded like an imposing statement now becomes the point of culmination.
At m. 45, Tempo primo restores the opening pace. The score now uses four staves, two for each hand, to distinguish the deep supporting notes from the higher groups of chords. No additional instrument or performer is involved. The layout simply makes the greatly expanded compass of the piano writing easier to read.
The decisive transformation lies in the chordal reply. At the beginning, it was marked ppp, almost distant; now the marking is fff pesante, exceptionally loud and weighty. Motto and reply become part of a single climax. The octaves and thick chords evoke a much larger ensemble, although only one pianist is playing.
![]() |
| Example 2 — Tempo primo, mm. 45–47: the chordal reply returns across four staves, marked fff pesante. Complete piano texture for two hands. Source: the same A. Gutheil / Breitkopf & Härtel impression, plate A. 6516 G., p. 4; Sibley Music Library, University of Rochester. The excerpt uses an undamaged system from this page. |
The two score examples make that transformation visible. Rhythmic outline and melodic direction remain recognisable, but dynamics, compass and chordal density have changed. For the performer, the challenge is to preserve the identity of the principal voices within so much sound. The diminuendo towards mm. 53–54 begins to release the pressure and leads into the closing passage.
Coda — The remaining resonance
In mm. 55–61 the low C-sharp is held or repeated beneath changing upper chords. This is a pedal point: one note persists while the harmony in the other voices moves on. After the dense activity of the preceding music, that steady bass produces calm without instantly removing all internal tension.
The wide space between bass and upper voices makes resonance part of the ending. The final chord confirms C-sharp minor at ppp, while a fermata allows the sound to linger. The piece does not end at the height of its climax: it gradually withdraws from it until only the quiet final sonority remains.
Bells, Resonance and the Pianist’s Touch
The association with bells arises chiefly from the way sound is struck and allowed to resonate. Each clearly defined attack leaves a vibration behind it, and the next arrives while that sound is still present. Low octaves, wide spacing between voices and carefully placed rests create a comparable sense of acoustic space at the piano. It is an interpretative way of hearing the score, not evidence that Rachmaninoff intended to describe particular bells or a specific place.
The sustaining pedal lifts the dampers, allowing notes struck at different moments to resonate together. It is essential to the Prelude’s sound, but needs careful control. Excessive blending can obscure chromatic changes; playing too dryly can weaken the continuity of the bass. The balance depends on the instrument and the acoustics of the room.
The balance of voices within each chord matters just as much. If every note receives equal emphasis, the melodic line can disappear into the mass of sound. In the powerful return, the opening motif and the direction of its chordal answer must remain audible. The enlarged sonority can then retain the clarity of the musical design.
🪶 A Chapter in the Life of the Work
A lifetime in C-sharp minor
In March 1933, at a concert in Philadelphia, Rachmaninoff had already returned to the piano to play two encores, the Humoresque and Daisies. The applause continued. According to the recollection of two friends, the music writer Alfred Swan and his wife Katherine, the pianist sat down again, looked at the keyboard and raised his hands towards the audience as though he had nothing more to offer. Someone called for a piece by naming only its key: “C-sharp minor.” Behind that brief request lay several decades of concert history.
The story began in Moscow in 1892. Rachmaninoff was nineteen and had just completed his composition studies at the city’s conservatory. On 8 October—26 September according to the calendar then used in Russia—he appeared as pianist at a concert at the Moscow Electrical Exhibition. The programme also included Chopin’s Berceuse and Liszt’s transcription of the waltz from Faust. Among these pieces, his own Prelude was heard in public for the first time. Its later fame, however, did not spring fully formed from that single evening.
In 1893 the music was published as the second of five Morceaux de fantaisie, Op. 3, a collection dedicated to Anton Arensky, the young composer’s composition teacher. Once the score was in circulation, the Prelude could travel independently of the rest of the set. Alexander Siloti—Rachmaninoff’s cousin, a pianist and his former piano teacher—played an important part in spreading it through his tours in 1898.
The following year, when Rachmaninoff visited London, he found that many young pianists already knew the piece. The Prelude had travelled ahead of its creator. Before his first American tour, he asked whether he was sufficiently well known to attract an audience; the reply identified him above all as the composer of the C-sharp minor Prelude. Writing about the experience in 1910, Rachmaninoff made clear that he wanted listeners to know his other music too. The success of one early work was beginning to narrow the public’s view of a composer whose career had continued to develop.
He did not respond to every request in the same way. On 21 December 1918, at a New York recital, listeners again asked for the Prelude. The critic James Huneker reported that some had moved towards the stage, pressing for the familiar piece. Rachmaninoff did not play it that evening. This is evidence of one refusal, not proof that he consistently disliked the music.
Years later, the Philadelphia scene ended differently. When the audience called once more for C-sharp minor, Rachmaninoff, as the Swans remembered, smiled, nodded and played the Prelude. More than forty years had passed since its first performance in Moscow. The same piece still accompanied its composer in concert—sometimes as a request he declined, and sometimes as the music with which he brought an evening to a close.
🎧 Listening Guide
At the opening, the most striking landmark is the distance between the fortissimo octaves and the chords that answer at ppp. The silence between them gives the resonance room to develop.
In the Agitato, the upper notes of the triplets form a melody moving more slowly than the surrounding figuration. Following them as one line brings out the chromatic descent E–D-sharp–D-natural–C-sharp.
As the music approaches the climax, the continuous triplet flow turns into a succession of forceful chords. The shift in density and weight prepares the return of the opening notes.
At the return, the call remains recognisable, but its chordal answer is transformed: once barely audible, it now becomes explosive, spanning a much wider range of the keyboard.
In the coda, low C-sharp persists beneath the changing chords. A revealing difference between performances is how much time the pianist gives the final sonority after the great dynamic intensity has subsided.
🎶 Further Listening
These three recordings suggest different listening priorities: the composer’s own pacing and phrasing, the balance within the layered piano writing, and the sense of continuity in a live performance.
- Sergei Rachmaninoff — historical Edison recording, disc 82187-R, issued in 1920 and available through the Library of Congress. This is a direct document of the composer as performer. It provides a starting point for comparisons of pacing and phrasing, with allowance for the limitations of early recording technology.
- Vladimir Ashkenazy — Rachmaninov: Preludes, Decca. Hearing the piece within the complete twenty-four Preludes places it beside the later collections. Within this particular work, a useful point of comparison is the balance between melodic direction and the weight of the returning chords.
- Andrejs Osokins — live encore performance, in the video accompanying this article. The concert presentation invites attention to the organisation of the entire short dramatic span, from the initial waiting time to the last resonance, within a single live performance.
📚 Further Reading
The critical edition, the history of the work’s reception, and Rachmaninoff’s own account illuminate different aspects of both the score and its concert life.
- Dominik Rahmer — Prélude c sharp minor op. 3 no. 2, Henle HN 1211, Preface and Comments. These explain the work’s textual history and differences between the autograph, printed sources and later editorial interventions. The distinction between authentic markings and additions by other editors is particularly useful.
- Karen M. Bottge — “Reading Adorno’s Reading of the Rachmaninov Prelude in C-sharp Minor: Metaphors of Destruction, Gestures of Power”, Music Theory Online 17/4, 2011. This study connects analysis with reception history and examines Adorno’s response to the work’s popularity. The value judgements under discussion belong to a particular critical perspective rather than a neutral assessment.
- Serge Rachmaninoff — “My Prelude in C Sharp Minor”, The Delineator 75/2, February 1910, p. 127. The composer’s account, excerpts from which appear in Bottge’s article, illuminates his relationship with the Prelude’s fame. It is best approached as a historical statement made at a particular moment in his career.
🔗 Related Works
The following pieces offer distinct comparisons of compression, repetition and piano sonority.
- Sergei Rachmaninoff — Prelude in G minor, Op. 23 No. 5: Strongly defined outer sections frame a more songful central passage. Comparison reveals another approach to ternary contrast and the expressive significance of a return.
- Frédéric Chopin — Prelude in C minor, Op. 28 No. 20: Compact chordal writing and the importance of dynamic change offer a useful parallel for the expressive weight a very short work can acquire.
- Claude Debussy — La cathédrale engloutie, from the first book of Préludes: Spacing, resonance and masses of chords create a different world of bell-like piano sound. The comparison concerns the treatment of the instrument and makes no assumption of direct historical influence.
- Franz Liszt — Funérailles, from Harmonies poétiques et religieuses, S.173/7: Low sonorities, processional weight and expansive piano climaxes provide a broader Romantic comparison in a work on a much larger scale.
🎼 Closing Reflection
After its last powerful return, the music does not hurry to finish. The low notes remain, the chords grow sparse, and resonance carries what no longer needs to be expressed in new notes. The silence that follows feels like part of the sound.
📖 Bibliography and Sources
This analysis is based on the Gutheil / Breitkopf & Härtel score preserved by the Sibley Music Library, with measure numbering and significant textual differences checked against Henle’s critical comments. The Prelude’s concert history was reconstructed from the Performance Diary, contemporary and later testimony, and scholarly studies. Where historical accounts survive here through later publications, that transmission is identified in the relevant bibliography entries.
Scores and critical editions
Rachmaninoff, Sergei. Prélude, Op. 3 No. 2. Moscow: A. Gutheil / Leipzig: Breitkopf & Härtel, undated later impression, plate A. 6516 G., pp. 2–5. Sibley Music Library, University of Rochester, M25.R119 op.3. Digital record and score.
Rachmaninoff, Sergei. Prélude in C Sharp Minor, Op. 3 No. 2, ed. Leopold Godowsky. St. Louis: Art Publication Society, 1923, Progressive Series Compositions 812, plate 812-6. Consulted as a supplementary historical print, with its editorial interventions distinguished from the original text. Digitised copy at IMSLP.
Rahmer, Dominik, ed. Prélude c sharp minor op. 3 no. 2. Fingering by Marc-André Hamelin. Munich: G. Henle Verlag, HN 1211, 2014. The Preface and Comments were consulted, particularly the observations on mm. 14–35, 45–49 and 60–61.
Rahmer, Dominik, ed. Morceaux de Fantaisie op. 3. Munich: G. Henle Verlag, HN 1491, 2022. Preface, especially p. V, and Comments, pp. 42–43.
Historical testimony and reception studies
Rachmaninoff, Serge. “My Prelude in C Sharp Minor”. The Delineator 75/2 (February 1910), p. 127. Consulted through the excerpts reproduced in Bottge, §§1.2 and 3.3–3.10; the complete original issue was not examined directly.
Swan, Alfred J., and Katherine Swan. “Rachmaninoff: Personal Reminiscences—Part II”. The Musical Quarterly 30/2 (April 1944), pp. 174–191, especially pp. 182–183. The Philadelphia episode was consulted through its reproduction in Rahmer’s Preface to HN 1211.
Bottge, Karen M. “Reading Adorno’s Reading of the Rachmaninov Prelude in C-sharp Minor: Metaphors of Destruction, Gestures of Power”. Music Theory Online 17/4 (December 2011). Full article.
Orga, Ateş. Notes to Demidenko plays Rachmaninov, Hyperion CDA66713, 1994; reissued as CDH55239. Consulted for the extract from James Huneker’s review of the recital of 21 December 1918. Notes and recording details.
Archives and recordings
Rachmaninoff Performance Diary. 26 September 1892, Julian calendar. Refers to the Papers of Sophie Satin, Sergei Rachmaninoff Archive, Library of Congress, ML31.R33, boxes 82–89.
Library of Congress. Prelude in C sharp minor op. 3, Sergei Rachmaninoff, Edison Diamond Disc 82187-R, issued 1920, LCCN 00694098. Recording and metadata.
Decca Classics. Rachmaninov: Preludes, Vladimir Ashkenazy, UPC 00028948328857. Official reissue entry.
Osokins, Andrejs. Rachmaninoff – Prelude in C Sharp minor Op 3 No 2 – A. Osokins encore. Video on the pianist’s channel.


