In 1831, Robert Schumann was just twenty-one and still finding his voice as a music critic. When he encountered Frédéric Chopin’s Variations on “Là ci darem la mano,” based on the famous duet from Mozart’s Don Giovanni, he was so deeply impressed that he wanted to share his enthusiasm with Leipzig’s musical public. He might have written a conventional review, discussing the composition’s merits before arriving at his verdict. Instead, he chose something far less predictable: a small, almost theatrical scene in which music becomes the occasion for a conversation among imaginary friends.
Eusebius enters the room quietly, carrying a score. Julius and Florestan are already there, but Eusebius takes care to conceal the title before placing the music in front of them. “Hats off, gentlemen, a genius!” he announces. Julius begins turning the pages, trying to imagine the music from its notes, while Florestan can hardly wait to hear it. The two friends settle into the window recess as Eusebius sits down at the piano. Only later is the mysterious composer’s name revealed: Frédéric Chopin. And with it comes an opus number so unexpectedly low—Op. 2—that the maturity of the music seems all the more astonishing.
The review appeared in the Allgemeine musikalische Zeitung on 7 December 1831. The scene was invented, but Schumann’s admiration was entirely genuine. Perhaps the most revealing detail is the way he distributes the roles. The exuberant declaration comes not from the impetuous Florestan, as one might expect, but from the more introspective Eusebius. Florestan, meanwhile, is captivated by the music without surrendering his critical judgment. He questions certain aspects of its construction and discovers elaborate dramatic images drawn from Mozart’s world. Julius shares his admiration but gently reminds him that the scenes a composition awakens in the imagination do not necessarily belong to the composer alone. They also belong to the experience of the person listening.
Through this imagined gathering, Schumann had discovered a way of writing about music without confining himself to a single judgment. He could be enthusiastic, doubtful, reflective and imaginative, allowing each response to speak in its own voice. His two principal companions, Florestan and Eusebius, would soon accompany him far beyond the pages of music criticism.
Two Friends He Had Never Met
A few months before that review appeared, on 1 July 1831, Schumann had introduced two rather unusual friends in his diary. He described them as especially dear to him, although he had never actually seen them. They were Florestan and Eusebius, two figures of his imagination who gradually acquired recognisable personalities and became inseparable from his artistic world.
Florestan generally embodied the impulsive, daring and restless side of the creative temperament. He could become swept up in an idea, defend unfamiliar music with passionate conviction or react sharply against convention. Eusebius, by contrast, was drawn towards inwardness, tenderness and reflection. Where Florestan seemed eager to move out into the world, Eusebius sought the time and quiet in which an emotion could deepen and reveal its meaning.
Yet the distinction was never absolute. Eusebius could express an unexpectedly bold enthusiasm, as he does in the Chopin review, while Florestan could be disarmed by a sudden memory. They were not rigid symbols but living literary characters, free to surprise even their creator. Much later, in the introduction to his collected musical writings of 1854, Schumann explained that he had invented contrasting artistic personalities in order to express different views of art. Between them he placed Master Raro, a mediating figure who sought to reconcile their opposing perspectives.
The idea of such companionship had deep roots in Schumann’s literary imagination. From an early age, he had been fascinated by Jean Paul, a writer whose fiction brought sensitivity, humour and abrupt changes of mood into a remarkably personal relationship. In his novel Flegeljahre, the twin brothers Walt and Vult possess strikingly different temperaments. One is dreamy and sensitive; the other is lively, quick-witted and unpredictable. During a masked ball, they exchange disguises, and Vult imitates his brother so convincingly that he even deceives the woman with whom he is dancing.
The literary kinship between these twins and Schumann’s two imaginary companions is easy to recognise, though it would be misleading to treat the characters as exact equivalents. Schumann himself left clearer evidence of the hold that the masked-ball scene had on his imagination. In a letter to his mother in 1832, he explicitly connected his Papillons, Op. 2, with that episode from Jean Paul’s novel. Literature had already begun to turn into music, and a few years later, music from that earlier work would return like a half-remembered thought in one of Florestan’s portraits.
Meanwhile, the two imaginary friends had acquired a larger circle of companions. This was the League of David, or Davidsbund, an invented fellowship of artists opposed to the so-called “Philistines.” In Schumann’s Romantic understanding, these were the defenders of conventional taste, those who valued technical display more readily than artistic substance. The music journal he co-founded in Leipzig in 1834, known as the Neue Zeitschrift für Musik, gave this imaginary league a genuine public platform.
Florestan and Eusebius could now debate, disagree and defend the values Schumann believed essential to music’s future. Their arguments were not merely a device for making criticism more entertaining. They allowed him to approach a work from several directions without suppressing the contradictions inherent in listening itself. This freedom would become even more fruitful when the two friends moved from the world of words into the music.
When the Characters Became Music
In Carnaval, Op. 9, published in 1837, Schumann created an entire world of miniature musical portraits. Among Pierrot and Harlequin, real people and imagined figures, appear Chopin, Paganini and the composer’s two familiar companions. Eusebius and Florestan occupy consecutive pieces, like two guests passing one another in the midst of the same celebration. Here, for the first time, their differences no longer need to be described in words. The notes themselves are enough.
Eusebius speaks through a melody that seems to follow its own sense of time. Groups of seven notes unfold above a sparse accompaniment, creating the impression that the music is breathing freely rather than submitting entirely to the measured pulse. The phrases emerge with great delicacy, while the initial stillness gradually acquires warmth and greater depth of sound. This is not a passive or motionless melancholy. It is a world in which the smallest changes of feeling matter more than any outward gesture.
Then Florestan appears, and the musical landscape changes almost violently. Accents, abrupt rhythmic displacements and restless phrases evoke a mind moving faster than its thoughts can be organised. Where Eusebius allowed time to expand, Florestan seems determined to seize it. The contrast is so striking that the two pieces might at first seem to belong to entirely different worlds.
And yet something unexpected happens in the midst of Florestan’s headlong music. The movement is interrupted, and a brief fragment from the earlier Papillons emerges. The familiar waltz seems to flicker across the memory before disappearing again. When it returns, Schumann places a small question in the score: “Papillon?”
That question mark is almost more touching than the musical quotation itself. Florestan, so restless and impetuous, seems to hesitate for a moment, as though something from the past has unexpectedly caught his attention. There is no need to assign the passage to a particular personal memory in Schumann’s life. The interruption speaks eloquently enough on its own. Within the character who embodies unrestrained energy, a moment of tender uncertainty has suddenly appeared.
This brief episode reveals why Florestan and Eusebius cannot be reduced to two opposing temperaments. Florestan carries something of Eusebius’s sensitivity, just as Eusebius has already shown himself capable of Florestan’s passionate enthusiasm. The music does more than confirm their differences. It complicates them, gives them human depth and allows something of one character to be recognised in the other.
The conversation becomes still more intimate in the Davidsbündlertänze (Dances of the League of David), Op. 6, first published in January 1838. Here Florestan and Eusebius are no longer simply musical portraits. Their names occupy the title page, in the place where a reader would ordinarily expect to find the composer’s name. Throughout the eighteen pieces, divided into two books, their initials appear sometimes separately and sometimes together, as though the dances had emerged from an ongoing exchange of ideas.
Yet beneath these two imaginary signatures, the presence of a real person is felt from the very beginning. The opening musical phrase, marked “Motto von C. W.,” comes from a mazurka by Clara Wieck, the young pianist and composer with whom Schumann had formed a profound attachment. Clara had accepted his proposal of marriage in August 1837, and he would later write to her that the dances contained many thoughts of their wedding. He even compared the atmosphere of the work to a Polterabend, the traditional German celebration held before a marriage, with all its lively commotion and unpredictable moments.
Clara’s presence therefore carries a significance that goes beyond personal affection. She is not simply a beloved figure standing behind the music as a source of inspiration. She enters the musical material as a composer in her own right. Her phrase becomes the starting point for a cycle in which Schumann allows his imaginary companions to express joy, anticipation, tenderness and anxiety in continually changing forms. Real life and the invented world are no longer separate. They have begun to speak the same musical language.
Towards the end of the second book, an earlier melody returns. The tender second piece is recalled within the seventeenth, under the marking Wie aus der Ferne—“as if from afar.” After so many changes of character, the return creates the impression that the music is looking back towards its beginning, recognising something it has already experienced. Yet the memory no longer sounds quite as it did before. An entire musical journey has taken place in between.
It would be natural to feel that the cycle could end here. Schumann, however, reserves one final surprise. In the first edition, before the eighteenth piece, he remarks with gentle humour that Eusebius felt compelled to add something more, quite unnecessarily, while great happiness shone in his eyes. What follows is a slow, quiet waltz.
After all the restlessness, the shifting moods and the sharp contrasts, the cycle does not conclude with a grand climax. It ends with a modest addition, almost like an afterthought spoken just as everyone believed the conversation had come to an end. Eusebius, who at the beginning of our story was the first to recognise Chopin’s genius, is now the one who wishes to keep the music alive a little longer. In that unassuming persistence lies an emotion that no resounding finale could have expressed in quite the same way.
When the Voices No Longer Needed Names
In 1838, with Kreisleriana, Op. 16, Schumann turned towards another beloved literary world: that of E. T. A. Hoffmann. The eccentric Kapellmeister Johannes Kreisler, a character whose life unfolds amid music, imagination and the contradictions of artistic existence, gave his name to the eight piano fantasies. The work was also closely connected with Clara. In a letter written that April, Schumann told her that she and the thought of her played the principal part in what he was composing, and that he wished to dedicate the pieces to her. Yet when the first edition appeared in Vienna, the dedication was addressed to Chopin.
The literary figure of Kreisler, the private confidence shared with Clara and the public dedication to Chopin surround the same music without carrying identical meanings. Each illuminates a different relationship between the composer and his world. Within the eight fantasies themselves, however, Florestan and Eusebius are nowhere named. There are no signatures assigning particular changes of musical character to one or the other.
And yet it is difficult to listen to these pieces without remembering their earlier appearances. In the second fantasy, a broad, tender melody is interrupted by two much livelier episodes. The music moves from tranquillity into agitation and returns once more, but each return has acquired a different weight. The melody is immediately recognisable, almost familiar, yet it sounds altered by everything that has happened in between. Its calm is no longer quite the calm of its first appearance.
It would be tempting to assign the tenderness to Eusebius and the restless energy to Florestan. Such a reading, however, would diminish the richness of the music. What matters more is the relationship between the different characters: how an agitated phrase changes the meaning of tranquillity, how a returning melody retains something of the tension that preceded it, and how contrast can become a deeper form of continuity. The two imaginary friends need not appear by name for something of their familiar conversation to be heard.
In the eighth and final fantasy, this sense of interplay takes on an almost playful character. The right hand unfolds a light, graceful melody while the lower notes of the left hand enter at unexpected points in the rhythm. The two lines seem to organise the same passage of time in different ways. The ear moves between them, searching for the relationship that holds them together. As the music approaches its ending, the motion descends into the piano’s lower register, and the sound fades almost imperceptibly.
There is no final declaration imposing reconciliation upon the two lines. Their relationship remains alive until the last notes, before giving way to silence. What had seemed like two different ways of speaking has acquired meaning through their coexistence. Neither line must retreat in order for the other to be heard.
Years later, in 1850, Schumann made a revealing change. When he revised the Davidsbündlertänze for a new edition, he removed the markings that attributed the individual pieces to Florestan and Eusebius. The two figures who had once occupied even the composer’s place on the title page no longer appeared as the music’s imaginary signatories.
The revision did not erase the contrasts within the work. The tender phrases, impetuous outbursts, recollections and unexpected changes remained. What had changed was the way the music presented itself to the reader of the score. Its shifting moods no longer came with names to guide their interpretation. They could be heard as parts of a single, many-sided creative expression.
Perhaps this is where the deeper significance of Florestan and Eusebius in Schumann’s world becomes clearest. They were not invented to divide his artistic nature into two incompatible halves, nor to provide a definitive explanation for its contradictions. They enabled him to explore those contradictions, to give them form and, above all, to let them converse.
Florestan could pause in the midst of an impetuous phrase, as though suddenly touched by an old memory. Eusebius could be the first to recognise a genius or add one last quiet dance when everything seemed complete. Each carried something of the other, and the most revealing moments often arose where the boundaries between them became uncertain.
The two voices were not rival claims upon a single soul. They were two ways of listening, thinking and creating music. And rather than choosing one at the expense of the other, Schumann discovered how much more he could express by allowing them to sound together.
📖 Bibliography & Sources
- Robert Schumann, “Ein Opus II,” Allgemeine musikalische Zeitung, vol. 33, no. 49, 7 December 1831, cols. 805–806. First publication — Yale University Library.
- Robert Schumann, “Einleitendes,” Gesammelte Schriften über Musik und Musiker, vol. 1, Leipzig, Georg Wigand, 1854. Digital transcription.
- Eric Frederick Jensen, Schumann, Oxford University Press, 2001. Historical documentation of the League of David and the earliest diary references to Florestan and Eusebius. Oxford Academic.
- Jean Paul, Flegeljahre. The literary world of the twins Walt and Vult and the masked-ball episode. German text.
- Robert Schumann, Carnaval, Op. 9, first German edition, Breitkopf & Härtel, Leipzig, 1837. Digitised score — Brahms-Institut Lübeck.
- Robert Schumann, Davidsbündlertänze, Op. 6, and Kreisleriana, Op. 16, ed. Ernst Herttrich, G. Henle Verlag. Prefaces and critical documentation of early editions, musical markings and correspondence. Davidsbündlertänze · Kreisleriana.
- John Daverio, Robert Schumann: Herald of a “New Poetic Age”, Oxford University Press, 1997. Historical and aesthetic context for Schumann’s literary imagination. Oxford Academic.
- John MacAuslan, Schumann’s Music and E. T. A. Hoffmann’s Fiction, Cambridge University Press, 2016. A study of the relationships between musical composition, literature and character in Schumann’s piano cycles. Cambridge University Press.

