Tchaikovsky: The Nutcracker, Act II — Analysis

Clara watches the Sugar Plum Fairy and her cavalier dance in the enchanted palace of Tchaikovsky’s Nutcracker, Act II
The adventure has brought Clara to a celebration whose world unfolds through dance. From the sweets’ brief appearances to the sustained lyricism of the grand Pas de deux, Act II gives the orchestra room to turn the joy of arrival into a musical climax.

At the end of the night’s adventure, Clara and the Nutcracker, now transformed into a prince, enter a kingdom where no further battle awaits them. Instead, they are welcomed with a celebration. In Act II of The Nutcracker, Tchaikovsky fills the palace with dances of strikingly different characters: the exuberant Trepak, the light-footed Dance of the Reed Flutes, the sweeping Waltz of the Flowers and the delicate Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy. Familiar as these pieces are, each belongs to a larger musical journey.

The early dances are brief, and each establishes its identity almost at once: a strongly marked rhythm, a persistent accompaniment, or an exchange between instruments in widely separated registers. Then the music begins to take its time. In the Waltz of the Flowers, melodies return and develop across longer stretches; in the grand Pas de deux, one simple idea grows until it carries the force of the full orchestra. The celebration moves from a procession of contrasting miniatures towards a sustained lyrical climax.

The slow section of the Pas de deux is especially revealing. Its main melody begins with a descending scale, hardly an elaborate invention on paper. Yet as the harmonies change, the accompaniment gathers momentum and the theme returns with greater orchestral weight, its expressive reach grows. This is where Act II shows itself to be far more than a collection of celebrated dances.

This analysis follows Nos. 10–15 of the complete orchestral score. The Nutcracker Work Guide introduces the literary background and the story as a whole, while the analysis of Act I follows the journey from the family house to the snowy forest. Here the focus is on the musical relationships that turn the travellers’ welcome into a complete second act.

The Story

With Clara’s help, the Nutcracker has defeated the Mouse King and been transformed into a prince. Their journey through the snowy forest brings them to Confiturenburg, the enchanted Kingdom of Sweets. At the palace, the Sugar Plum Fairy welcomes them and listens as the Prince recounts the battle. When he tells the court that Clara saved him, their reception becomes a celebration in her honour.

The sweets and the inhabitants of the kingdom now appear in a succession of dances: chocolate in the Spanish Dance, coffee in the Arabian Dance and tea in the Chinese Dance. The Russian Trepak follows, then the Dance of the Reed Flutes and Mother Gigogne. From beneath her enormous skirt emerge the little Polichinelles, turning the last appearance of this sequence into a comic spectacle. She is often called Mother Ginger in English-speaking productions.

With the Waltz of the Flowers, the festivities expand into a large ensemble scene. Next comes the Pas de deux, comprising a slow dance for two, two solo variations and a closing coda. In the original 1892 production, the Sugar Plum Fairy and her cavalier were distinct from Clara and the Nutcracker Prince. Many later stagings rearrange those roles, making the grand classical dance a more direct part of the central couple’s story.

The Final Waltz restores the movement of the whole company and leads into the Apotheosis. The theatrical ending varies between productions: a return to the house and Clara’s awakening belong to particular choreographic versions. The score brings the celebration to its own extended conclusion.

Movements / Structure

Act II forms the third scene of the ballet’s original two-act design. Its opening numbers establish the setting and connect the visitors with the festivities. The divertissement then introduces six distinct musical characters before the act moves towards its larger dances. The table follows the order of the ballet and the opening markings in Jurgenson’s edition as reprinted by Broude Brothers. The keys indicate each dance’s principal orientation rather than every harmonic departure within it.

NumberSection and principal markingTonal and rhythmic orientation
10The Enchanted Palace — AndanteE major, 6/8
11Arrival of Clara and the Nutcracker — Andante con moto, with subsequent tempo changesOpens in C major; music for welcome and narration
12aChocolate — Spanish Dance, Allegro brillanteE-flat major, 3/4
12bCoffee — Arabian Dance, CommodoG minor, 3/8
12cTea — Chinese Dance, Allegro moderatoB-flat major, 4/4
12dTrepak — Russian Dance, Tempo di trepak, molto vivaceG major, 2/4; concludes Prestissimo
12eDance of the Reed Flutes — Moderato assaiD major, 2/4
12fMother Gigogne and the Polichinelles — Allegro giocoso, with a slower intervening sectionA major, 2/4
13Waltz of the Flowers — Tempo di ValseD major, 3/4
14aPas de deux — Andante maestosoG major, 4/4
14bFirst Variation, for the male dancer — Tempo di TarantellaB minor, 6/8
14cSecond Variation, Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy — Andante non troppoE minor, 2/4; a fast conclusion
14dCoda — Vivace assaiD major, 2/4
15Final Waltz and Apotheosis — Tempo di Valse, followed by Molto menoOpens in B-flat major; the ballet concludes in C major

Act II is not organised like a symphonic movement working towards the return of a single home key. Its continuity emerges instead from the sequence of dances, their proportions and their changing orchestral colours. The G major of the slow Pas de deux and the E minor of the Sugar Plum Fairy’s variation, for example, illuminate contrasting parts of one larger dance design. The Final Waltz brings the company back together after the individual appearances.

Musical Analysis

No. 10 — Giving the palace a sound

The palace is introduced before the travellers’ musical arrival. The Andante in 6/8 begins with both harps tracing continuous descending and folding figures against sustained brass chords. The distinction is easy to hear: the harp notes move rapidly while the harmonic support holds its place. Tchaikovsky establishes a setting capable of sustaining attention, rather than announcing another confrontation.

E major supplies the scene’s initial brightness, while changes of instrumentation reveal successive aspects of its sound. The celesta already participates here. Its colour is therefore not reserved exclusively for the Sugar Plum Fairy’s famous variation; it helps identify the entire place the travellers have reached. Around the developing melodic phrases, harps and upper instruments preserve a mobile surface.

The new beginning also changes the act’s dramatic scale. The great conclusion of the snow scene has been left behind, and a different kind of opening is required. Sustained chords provide stability, the harps keep the music flowing, and the gradual redistribution of colour allows the palace to appear in sound before its individual inhabitants take the foreground.

No. 11 — Arrival and the recollection of battle

The travellers’ arrival is marked by an unusual orchestral effect. The stage direction describes a river of rose water, while all three flutes play flutter-tonguing: the tongue vibrates rapidly as the player blows, producing a gently trembling sound. Tchaikovsky even explains the technique in the score. Combined with the quick movement of strings, celesta and harps, the flutes give the scene a more fluid, restless texture than the palace’s earlier introduction.

What follows accommodates both reception and mime. Phrases alter their length and pace to make room for different actions: recognising the visitors, hearing the Prince’s account and responding to his story. As the battle is recalled, the orchestra brings back agitated movement and material associated with the earlier conflict. Act I’s danger is now being remembered within the safety of the welcome.

That recollection supplies the reason for the dances about to begin. The celebrations grow out of a rescue that has just been acknowledged. Even without the stage picture, the passage from agitated episodes towards a more settled reception makes the change of perspective intelligible. The remembered event gives way to the present gathering, and the music prepares a new kind of continuity.

No. 12a — Chocolate and the trumpets’ bright entrance

The Spanish Dance opens the divertissement with a clearly defined rhythmic profile. In E-flat major and 3/4, its accompaniment distributes the positions of the bar between lower strings, the other strings’ chords and horns. Above this foundation, two trumpets come into prominence. Their short ascending figures and animated endings give the melody the character of a public appearance.

The brightness does not depend on an uninterrupted full orchestral sound. Melodic movement also passes to the woodwinds, the writing becomes more agile, and the return of stronger figures consequently carries greater weight. Castanets reinforce the dance’s theatrical Spanish identity. A useful focus is the relationship between the steady triple-time accompaniment and the lively, often ornamented line above it: the scene establishes its character immediately and closes before a brief appearance becomes an extended development.

No. 12b — Coffee and the persistence of the lower strings

In the Arabian Dance, time seems to slow down. Muted violas and cellos repeat a short figure in G minor. Although the metre is 3/8, the subdued dynamics and soft, steady motion do not emphasise a pronounced dance step. The accompaniment establishes its rhythm well before the melody has fully unfolded.

Above this foundation, the cor anglais and clarinets sustain longer notes, shaping small melodic turns and ornaments. The accompaniment remains recognisable while the melody changes: this is an ostinato, a short musical pattern that returns persistently. The veiled tone of the lower strings brings even slight changes in the winds into sharper relief. The contrast concerns instrumental colour as much as rhythm.

The scene gains variety without abandoning that basis. The melody moves between instruments, violins add decorative figures, and the tambourine intervenes discreetly. Towards the end, the sound withdraws while the little recurring movement continues. Listening first to the accompaniment, then to the melody, reveals two different kinds of activity within the same span. One layer persists; the other changes the direction and colour of the time unfolding above it.

No. 12c — Tea between the high flute and low bassoons

In the brief Chinese Dance, the distance between registers becomes the music’s defining feature. Two bassoons play low, detached notes, and the first flute answers high above them with a quick rising figure and small ornaments. Because the voices are so widely separated, each entrance is unmistakable. This almost playful exchange gives the miniature its distinctive sound within a few bars.

Selected first-flute and bassoon staves from the Chinese Dance in The Nutcracker
Example 1. Act II, No. 12c, bars 1–4, with no upbeat. Selected staves for first flute and two bassoons, placed consecutively while retaining the original horizontal alignment of the bars. Low staccato movement precedes the high melodic entrance. Source: P. Jurgenson, Moscow, 1892; Broude Brothers reprint, New York, 1951, plate B.B. 47, p. 337; IMSLP #03570. This is a selection of staves, not the complete orchestra.

The example makes the flute’s initial wait visible. By the time it enters, the bassoons’ accompanying figure is already recognisable, so the high line adds an unmistakably different musical behaviour. The bassoons’ sempre staccato preserves their separated articulation even while the melody connects several fast notes.

B-flat major provides a stable tonal setting. Variety comes principally from register, small instrumental additions and returns to the opening exchange. Such a short form needs an identity that can be grasped at once. The flute and bassoons establish it before the act moves on to another character.

No. 12d — The Trepak gathers its energy

The Trepak begins in G major and 2/4 with forceful collective movement. Its compact opening figure, sharp accents and quick string writing make the pulse immediately recognisable. Winds add detached responses and supporting notes, while the tambourine later strengthens the rhythmic drive.

The energy does not remain unchanged from beginning to end. Tchaikovsky briefly lightens the orchestral texture, allows a contrasting passage to emerge and then brings the opening material back with increasing force. The result is a compact three-part shape: initial statement, contrast and return. Rhythm and crisp articulation make the reprise especially easy to recognise.

The final Prestissimo turns accumulated energy into acceleration. More events pass through the same amount of time as the familiar dance framework becomes compressed. Following the Arabian Dance’s lingering persistence and the Chinese Dance’s delicate contrasts, the Trepak supplies a decisive burst of movement within the divertissement.

No. 12e — The three flutes of the Mirlitons

The Dance of the Reed Flutes changes the orchestra’s proportions again. Three flutes form a small melodic ensemble in D major, while the strings’ accompaniment, often pizzicato, keeps their outlines clear. The first flute is not simply a solo voice over an undifferentiated background. Neighbouring lines move with it, giving the melody a compact harmonic body.

The French title, Les Mirlitons, refers to small popular instruments with a vibrating membrane; the music itself is played on orchestral flutes. Its pastoral impression comes from that choice of colour, balanced phrasing and a gentle duple pulse. Ascents, rapid turns and small accents keep the line animated within its restrained manner.

The middle episode changes the weight of the sound. Brass and a denser accompaniment become more prominent, while F-sharp minor darkens the tonal colour. When the flutes return in D major, the effect is a genuine restoration: the melody is recognised together with its lighter instrumental setting. The little scene thus traces a clear arc between two different orchestral conditions.

No. 12f — Mother Gigogne and the comic spectacle

The last number of the divertissement restores a more public, theatrical exuberance. In A major, the lower strings begin with quick ascending and descending movement, while horns and tambourine supply sharply defined rhythmic support. The woodwinds then introduce the melodic activity. The bustle is carefully organised: different groups have specific recurring tasks.

A slower intervening section allows a more songlike manner of phrasing. Its contrast serves the stage play between the large mother figure and her lively little company without requiring every musical figure to be arbitrarily assigned to a particular child or step. When quick movement returns, the comic display gathers its concluding momentum.

The number’s position is significant. The divertissement ends with figures from comedy and play before the act opens into the Waltz of the Flowers’ greater lyrical span. The change will be felt partly as a difference in musical duration: the succession of small appearances gives way to a scene that has time to develop.

No. 13 — The Waltz of the Flowers opens out the dance

The Waltz of the Flowers does not begin with its familiar dance step. Wind chords alternate with harp arpeggios until the harp takes an extended, written-out cadenza on its own. The marking ad libitum allows some flexibility in pacing. This introduction creates anticipation: the regular waltz pulse will only take hold after the harp has completed its passage.

As the waltz pulse settles, the horns introduce the melody quietly, dolce cantabile. Their rounded sound differs from the Spanish Dance’s bright trumpets, allowing the phrase to unfold with a broader breath. Clarinets answer and continue the line, while the strings preserve the bar’s recurring three-beat movement.

D major supports the principal dance setting, but the number contains more than one tune repeated at length. New phrases appear in violins and woodwinds. Later, violas and cellos bring a broader singing line into the foreground beneath the violins’ smaller figures. Attention passes from the brighter surface to a lower, more sustained melodic presence.

Returns to earlier ideas connect these areas. A familiar melody acquires different weight when more instruments and stronger dynamics support it. The longer timescale allows a course to emerge from the first restrained appearance towards full orchestral movement. The beat remains a reliable point of orientation while phrasing and orchestration continually alter the balance around it.

Towards the end, the concluding accumulation gathers the orchestra as a whole. Its brilliant arrival in D major differs from the Trepak’s brief explosion: there has been time for contrast, recognition and return. The large ensemble scene is complete, and attention can now turn towards two dancers.

No. 14a — The Pas de deux and the power of a descending scale

In the G-major Andante maestoso, the great melody does not arrive immediately. First come the first harp’s triplet arpeggios, the second harp’s chords and the strings’ pizzicato pulse. This calm but continuous movement provides the foundation for the cellos’ entrance in bar four, marked fortissimo. The moment is remarkable not only for its force but for the simplicity of the melody itself.

Harp and string staves from bars 3 to 5 of the slow Pas de deux
Example 2. Act II, No. 14a, bars 3–5, counted from the first complete bar; there is no upbeat. The two harps and five string staves are reproduced. The cello entrance in bar 4 stands above an accompaniment already in motion. Source: P. Jurgenson, Moscow, 1892; Broude Brothers reprint, New York, 1951, plate B.B. 47, p. 419; IMSLP #03572. These are the active staves of this system, not the ballet’s full orchestral forces.

Its first movement is a descending scale. Tchaikovsky does not present it as a neutral sequence of notes: the opening pitch is held, the following notes begin to move, and the phrase continues beyond the initial descent. The dynamics fall away sharply within the line, changing its expressive weight. Such elementary melodic material becomes the starting point for an extended lyrical development.

Across the first broad section, that melody develops over the harps’ continuing motion and gains more orchestral support. A thinner, more mobile continuation follows. Short wind phrases, harp interventions and harmonic changes interrupt the certainty of the opening flow. This contrast prepares the great theme’s return. Its reappearance is recognised both through the descending line and through the restoration of the broader pace.

When the theme returns, the orchestration carries it steadily towards a major climax. The harmony moves through new stages, string figures grow denser, and woodwind and brass add increasing weight. The descending line remains recognisable, but its scale has changed: what began as a cello melody has become the voice of the entire orchestra.

After the climax, Tchaikovsky gradually reduces the density and brings the harp forward again. The closing calm allows the large shared phrase to end before the two soloists separate. The expressive course begun by a spare descending line has needed the participation of the entire orchestra to unfold.

No. 14b — The first variation and the speed of the tarantella

The first solo variation moves into B minor and the tarantella’s 6/8. Flutes begin quick melodic turns, with cor anglais and bassoons supporting the flow through more restrained movement. After the Andante maestoso’s sustained duration, energy is immediately concentrated into smaller units.

Rapid articulation allows the male dancer’s solo presence to come into focus. More instruments join, the running figures pass between voices, and the final strengthening gives the brief solo a conclusion of its own. Here, “variation” belongs to the vocabulary of ballet and means a self-contained solo dance. It does not require the music to vary the theme of the preceding slow section.

No. 14c — The Sugar Plum Fairy and the celesta’s measured brilliance

In the Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy, the orchestra suddenly contracts to the smallest of sounds. In E minor and 2/4, a few strings play soft pizzicato notes at pianissimo, leaving small spaces between them. The celesta waits through four complete bars before entering in the fifth. By then the accompaniment is familiar, and nothing obscures the new instrument’s fragile, bell-like melody.

Celesta and selected string staves at the opening of the Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy
Example 3. Act II, No. 14c, bars 1–7, with no upbeat. Selected celesta and string staves. The celesta’s four initial bars of rest allow the accompaniment to establish itself before the melodic entrance. The score expressly limits the number of string players and permits piano if a celesta is unavailable. Source: P. Jurgenson, Moscow, 1892; Broude Brothers reprint, New York, 1951, plate B.B. 47, p. 451; IMSLP #03572.

The celesta’s metallic sound has a brief attack and delicate resonance. Its little rests, rapid ornaments and chords need no great volume to stand apart because the accompaniment remains transparent. Bass clarinet adds low responses, creating another contrast between high and low registers. This exchange is more restrained than the Chinese Dance’s comic interplay.

The melody temporarily moves away from its opening shape and returns, with harmony and small changes of accompaniment altering the colour around it. A final acceleration gathers the scene into a short virtuoso close. The familiar brilliance of the instrument therefore has a precise function within the larger design. After the extended shared lyricism and the first variation’s quick movement, attention settles on a delicate, closely controlled solo appearance.

No. 14d — The coda brings the couple together

The Vivace assai in D major restores quick duple movement. Horns establish recurring rhythmic supports, and the strings add melodic phrases with marked differences of articulation. Following the celesta’s finely scaled writing, the orchestra can acquire greater weight again.

The coda gathers the two solos’ virtuoso energy into a shared conclusion. Short figures, successive increases in force and clear closing chords complete the couple’s theatrical appearance. The Pas de deux has now passed through four distinct experiences of time: a broad lyrical span, the tarantella’s speed, delicately articulated solo movement and a final common impulse.

No. 15 — From the Final Waltz to the Apotheosis

The Final Waltz returns to the whole celebration. Its B-flat-major opening brings forceful orchestral participation and a clear three-beat pulse. The melody develops through successive phrases and changes of colour, allowing the figures on stage to meet again in collective movement.

This return to waltz time serves a different purpose from No. 13. There, the music opened a large independent dance; here, dancing gathers the act together after the individual appearances. Contrasting dynamics and the alternation of more agile and broader phrases keep the movement active without requiring a reprise of every earlier tune.

At Molto meno, the Apotheosis changes the proportions of musical time. Over the rapid, continuous movement of celesta and harps, longer melodic notes unfold with ceremonial breadth. The interest lies in the coexistence of those two layers: the smaller notes keep circulating as the main melody moves much more slowly. The finale gains breadth without losing the quiet animation beneath its surface.

The concluding C major, strengthened by the full orchestra, gives the ballet a decisive close. The act has travelled from the palace’s first appearance in sound through comic miniatures, large dances and sustained lyricism. The Apotheosis allows time for that entire world to reach its conclusion before the curtain falls.

The Bolshoi Theatre production, with the theatre’s orchestra conducted by Pavel Klinichev; choreography and libretto by Yuri Grigorovich. The heroine is named Marie in this production and is danced by Anna Nikulina. The staging follows its own theatrical version; the analysis above retains the numbering of the original complete score. Playback begins at 6:15 in the upload.

How the celebration holds together

In ballet, a divertissement is a succession of self-contained dances within a larger spectacle. The dances do not need to share a single theme to form a convincing sequence. In The Nutcracker, the Spanish Dance foregrounds rhythm and trumpets; the Arabian Dance sets a persistent accompaniment against a freer melody; and the Chinese Dance relies on the distance between flute and bassoons. Their ordering creates variety while sustaining the stage celebration.

After these brief, sharply differentiated appearances, the Waltz of the Flowers changes the sense of duration. Its melodies return after longer intervals and are recognised in fresh orchestral settings. The slow Pas de deux takes that expansion further, developing one idea on the way to a large-scale climax. The act holds together, then, not simply because its characters are celebrating, but because Tchaikovsky shapes the musical time of the celebration.

The dances’ geographical titles belong to the theatrical vocabulary of Imperial ballet. Sweets are presented through recognisable stage characters and orchestral colours. The score does not offer a comprehensive or faithful account of every musical tradition named by those titles. Specific uses of castanets, insistent accompaniment or contrasting registers explain the scenes’ workings more accurately than a general appeal to “national colour.”

Small repetitions and a large melody

The Arabian Dance and the slow Pas de deux share an easily heard feature: small accompanying figures continue beneath a more slowly moving melody. But they do not serve the same purpose. In the Arabian Dance, the repeated pattern keeps the melodic setting almost unchanged. In the Pas de deux, the harps’ arpeggios accompany shifting harmonies, thematic returns and the gradual expansion of the orchestra.

The difference becomes clear when the direction of the music is followed. In the Arabian Dance, small changes matter because the foundation remains stable. In the Andante maestoso, each new harmonic stage and each addition to the orchestral sound creates a sense of what may come next. A continuing accompaniment can therefore sustain an atmosphere in one dance and support a far-reaching dramatic development in another.

🪶 A Chapter in the Life of the Work

When the dances left the palace

In May 1935, artists at Walt Disney’s studio were discussing a project in which flowers would become dancers. It was to be called Ballet des Fleurs — a ballet of flowers. The studio had already experimented with giving the natural world movement in its short animated films, but this particular project was never completed as a film in its own right. The idea did not disappear. A few years later, elements of it would find an unexpected home among the dances of The Nutcracker.

Meanwhile, Disney had begun collaborating with Leopold Stokowski, the conductor who would lead the music for their new film project. At first they envisaged a short feature based on The Sorcerer’s Apprentice. Gradually it grew into a full programme in which different musical works would be given distinct visual worlds. In spring 1939, the Philadelphia Orchestra recorded music for Fantasia under Stokowski’s baton. For the studio artists, those orchestral performances were not simply background sound. The images had to take shape within the music’s own timing and character.

Among the artists who helped shape the sequence were Bianca Majolie and Sylvia Moberly-Holland. Their early designs, delicate colours and small imaginary creatures helped create a celebration unlike the one in the theatre. The challenge was not merely to place a flower or mushroom on the screen. Each figure needed a recognisable way of moving, one that would make sense alongside the phrases and rhythms of the score.

By the time the dances reached the screen, Clara, the Prince and the palace of sweets had disappeared from the story. In their place came fairies, blossoms, fish and small mushrooms. In the Chinese Dance, the mushrooms made sharp, compact movements to the contrast between the high flute and the low bassoons. A painted animation cel from that scene survives in the Smithsonian’s National Museum of American History. Behind the brief sequence, it reveals something of the painstaking work that brought the figures to life.

The change of medium did not erase the music’s connection with dance. Blossoms turned; little figures advanced, paused and began moving again, much as dancers might on a stage. Tchaikovsky had not written for mushrooms or underwater creatures. But the distinctive rhythms and orchestral colours of the short dances gave the animators clear musical points of reference. The ballet had found another kind of life, made from drawings succeeding one another on the screen.

Fantasia premiered in New York on 13 November 1940. Its audiences saw selected dances from The Nutcracker, not the complete ballet and not a filmed performance of its original story. The American stage history followed a different path. On Christmas Eve 1944, San Francisco Ballet presented the first complete production of the work in the United States. Between those two dates lies a revealing distinction: the same music had reached audiences both as an animated fantasy and as a full theatrical ballet.

Returning to the complete score of Act II reveals what the celebrated film selection leaves out: the Spanish Dance, Mother Gigogne, the expansive slow Pas de deux and the final Apotheosis. On stage, the short dances are not isolated entertainments. They prepare the larger spans that follow, until the orchestra brings the entire celebration to its close. Fantasia gave the melodies new protagonists; the complete act restores their place in Tchaikovsky’s broader musical design.

🎧 Listening Guide

In No. 10, the harps’ quick figures stand out against the long-held brass chords. In No. 11, the flutes’ flutter-tonguing gives the sound a trembling quality associated with the stage image of a river of rose water. These are two contrasting ways of introducing the enchanted kingdom through orchestral colour.

In the Arabian Dance, the lower accompaniment supplies a fixed point of reference. Staying with it for several phrases makes the melody’s freedom above it clearer. In the Chinese Dance, shifting attention from bassoons to flute reveals how much of the character comes from the distance between their registers.

In the Trepak, the quick opening can be distinguished from the acceleration at the close. In the Reed Flutes, the flute ensemble’s return becomes especially clear after the heavier central episode. Recognition involves both melody and its instrumental colour.

The Waltz of the Flowers offers a particularly useful landmark where the harp cadenza ends and the settled dance pulse welcomes the horns. Later, the lower strings’ singing line provides a different point of focus within the same waltz.

In the slow Pas de deux, the cellos’ entrance in bar four provides a melodic point of reference. When the same descending idea returns in the full orchestra, its changed expressive weight is unmistakable. In the Sugar Plum Fairy’s dance, the celesta is heard only after four bars of delicate accompaniment. Finally, in the Apotheosis, the long melodic notes can be heard above the quicker, continuous figures of harps and celesta.

🎶 Further Listening

These complete recordings allow Act II to be heard through Nos. 10–15, beyond the concert suite’s selection. The suggested points of attention offer specific routes for comparison.

  • André Previn — London Symphony Orchestra, Warner Classics. The complete account provides an uninterrupted route from the palace to the Apotheosis. In the Waltz of the Flowers and the Pas de deux, a useful focus is the relationship between a continuing pulse and the development of the longer phrase.
  • Antal Doráti — London Symphony Orchestra, Mercury / Decca. This second complete recording provides a companion hearing of the divertissement. Comparisons can centre on spacing between notes, small dynamic contrasts and the Trepak’s concluding acceleration.
  • Vladimir Jurowski — State Academic Symphony Orchestra of Russia “Evgeny Svetlanov,” Pentatone, 2019. The complete ballet brings the introductory scenes into the same listening sequence as the familiar dances. A second hearing can follow the continuity of the harps and the changing weight of the strings between the palace and the grand Pas de deux.

📚 Further Reading

  • Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky — Casse-Noisette, Op. 71, complete orchestral score, P. Jurgenson, 1892; Broude Brothers reprint, 1951. Pages 268–511 contain the whole second act. Comparing the Sugar Plum Fairy’s sparse writing with the slow Pas de deux’s orchestral expansion is especially revealing.
  • Roland John Wiley — Tchaikovsky’s Ballets: Swan Lake, Sleeping Beauty, Nutcracker, Clarendon Press, 1985; Oxford University Press reprint, 1991. Musical analysis is connected with the original productions and historical documents surrounding their creation. This is a substantial next step for studying the relationship between theatrical planning and the score.
  • Alexander Rannie — “5 Fascinating Facts About Fantasia’s Nutcracker Suite,” D23, 2015. The article explores specific aspects of the dances’ cinematic transformation, from the earlier flower-ballet project to the contributions of the studio’s artists and technicians.

🔗 Related Works

  • Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky — The Sleeping Beauty, Op. 66, Act III: the wedding festivities likewise bring together fairy-tale appearances and a grand classical dance. The comparison illuminates the divertissement’s place within the concluding architecture of a ballet.
  • Léo Delibes — Coppélia, Act III: its festive sequence offers another transition from adventure to collective celebration. The relationship between short numbers and a larger final spectacle makes a useful point of comparison.
  • Maurice Ravel — Ma mère l’Oye, ballet version: instrumental colours distinguish the fairy-tale settings, while the concluding fairy garden traces another path towards orchestral fulfilment.
  • Sergei Prokofiev — Cinderella, Op. 87: the waltz participates more directly in the unfolding story and the changing experience of theatrical time. Comparing it with Act II’s waltzes shows how the same dance type can answer different dramatic needs.

🎼 Closing Reflection

In the Kingdom of Sweets, Clara watches a celebration made possible by her own courage. Brief dances follow one another until the music opens into broad, luminous phrases. For a little while, the adventure asks nothing more of her; there is only the pleasure of being there. And as the festivities draw to a close, something remains of that childhood moment we would like to hold on to, just a little longer.

📖 Bibliography and Sources

The analysis draws on direct examination of the complete orchestral score of Act II, using the reprint of Jurgenson’s first edition. Tempo markings, instrumental details and the musical examples follow that source rather than being transferred automatically from the suite. The account of the dances’ cinematic reception was checked against archival and museum records. Wiley’s publication details and contents were verified for the further-reading recommendation; the book is not represented as having been read in full for this article.

Score

Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky, Casse-Noisette. Ballet-féerie en 2 actes, Op. 71. Moscow: P. Jurgenson, 1892, plate 17668; reprinted New York: Broude Brothers, 1951, plate B.B. 47. Act II, pp. 268–511. IMSLP digital collection: files #03568–#03573. Examples reproduce material from pp. 337, 419 and 451.

Historical and musicological documentation

Tchaikovsky Research, “The Nutcracker”: chronology, performing forces, structure, composition and premiere. Its compressed synopsis is read alongside the original cast list.

The Marius Petipa Society, “The Nutcracker”: original cast, distinguishing the Nutcracker Prince from Prince Coqueluche, and the history of the production.

Los Angeles Philharmonic, “The Nutcracker, Act II”: an introduction to the second act and the Pas de deux’s lyrical expansion. Its stage synopsis is not treated as a universal account of every production.

Encyclopædia Britannica, 11th edition, “Eunuch Flute”, 1911: a historical description of the mirliton and its vibrating membrane, in the Wikisource transcription.

The dances on screen

American Film Institute, Fantasia (1940), AFI Catalog: production history, recording, premiere, credits and description of the Nutcracker sequence.

Alexander Rannie, “5 Fascinating Facts About Fantasia’s Nutcracker Suite”, D23, 2015: the Ballet des Fleurs project and its subsequent incorporation into Fantasia.

Frank Teurlay, “Program Recap—Heinrich Kley and Company”, The Walt Disney Family Museum, 2012: an account of John Canemaker’s presentation on the visual contributions of Bianca Majolie and Sylvia Moberly-Holland.

Philip Mayard, “Fantasia in Eight Parts: The Nutcracker Suite”, The Walt Disney Family Museum, 2012: the sequence’s relationship with dancing and its chronology relative to the complete American stage production of 1944.

National Museum of American History, Smithsonian Institution, “Animation cel of dancing mushrooms from Fantasia”: a surviving artefact from the Chinese Dance.

Library of Congress, “Fantasia, 1940”, Molto Animato! Music and Animation: Stokowski, the orchestra and the film’s use of selected music from the suite.

San Francisco Ballet, “History”, entry for 1944: the first complete production of the ballet in the United States.

Recording and publication records

Warner Classics, The Nutcracker — André Previn / London Symphony Orchestra.

Decca Classics, Tchaikovsky: The Nutcracker — Antal Doráti / London Symphony Orchestra.

Pentatone, Tchaikovsky — The Nutcracker — Vladimir Jurowski / State Academic Symphony Orchestra of Russia “Evgeny Svetlanov”, 2019, PTC 5186761.

Oxford University Press, Roland John Wiley, Tchaikovsky’s Ballets: Swan Lake, Sleeping Beauty, Nutcracker, publication record for the 1991 reprint.