Domenico Scarlatti - Sonata in G Minor, K.30 “Cat’s Fugue” (Analysis)

Domenico Scarlatti Sonata in G minor K.30 Cat’s Fugue
Scarlatti’s Sonata K.30 brings an unconventional subject into a sustained contrapuntal design, shaped by recurring entries and adventurous harmonic movement. The history of the “Cat’s Fugue” connects the music with a tradition whose surviving traces reach back into the eighteenth century.

Domenico Scarlatti’s Sonata in G minor, K.30, is the fugue that closes the thirty Essercizi per gravicembalo. Its familiar nickname, the “Cat’s Fugue”, comes from a story about an animal walking across a keyboard and supplying the composer with the opening notes of his subject. Yet the piece has a strong identity beyond the anecdote: an unconventional melodic outline supports an extended contrapuntal design, with continuous movement and a carefully prepared conclusion.

“Sonata” here does not mean a multi-movement Classical work or a movement in sonata form. The first edition identifies the piece as Sonata XXX and Fuga, within a collection entitled Essercizi. K.30 is its place in Ralph Kirkpatrick’s catalogue; L.499 comes from Alessandro Longo’s earlier classification. These numbers identify the music, but cannot by themselves supply a secure date of composition.

The collection appeared in London around 1738–1739, dedicated to King João V of Portugal. Publication and composition need to be kept distinct: the fugue’s position in the printed sequence is clear, whereas the precise circumstances in which it was written, and its first performance, remain undocumented. Its transmission through different printed and manuscript sources also shows that its history extends beyond that original sequence.

As the last of the Essercizi, K.30 asks for a change in the listener’s attention. Much of the collection explores rapid movement, leaps and hand crossings; the final Moderato gives the ear time to follow separate voices. Virtuosity remains essential, but its demands include independence of line, continuity of pulse and the articulation of changing harmonies. Speed alone cannot meet them.

The nickname deserves a more careful history than either literal acceptance or dismissal as a recent invention. An eighteenth-century manuscript already records the story. That evidence tells us something about the music’s circulation and reception, without establishing that a real cat dictated its subject. The most useful starting point for analysis is what can be checked directly: the notes, the entries and the changing function of familiar material as the fugue proceeds.

Movements / Structure

K.30 is a single movement in 6/8, without the two repeated halves familiar from many Scarlatti sonatas. Its continuity depends on successive statements of the subject, episodes between those statements and an extended closing region. The areas below describe functions within an uninterrupted process, rather than separate movements or sections carrying titles supplied by the composer.

AreaFunctionWhat to listen for
Opening presentationSubject, answer and further entries in lower registers.Slow ascending notes remain recognisable against the movement of other voices.
Entries and episodesThematic statements alternate with sequences and local cadences.Shorter patterns come forward when the complete subject is temporarily absent.
Closing regionA more stable bass foundation supports the final cadence.Moving upper parts ultimately settle into a G major chord.

The work does not rely on the return of a contrasting second theme. Instead, each entry is heard against a memory of earlier statements, while harmonic movement and changing density prevent the process from becoming static. The major final chord belongs to the conclusion of a work in G minor; it does not require us to relabel the piece’s overall key.

Musical Analysis

The subject: six slow notes and a quicker descent

Scarlatti begins with a single line. Its first six pitches are G – B flat – E flat – F sharp – B flat – C sharp, each a dotted crotchet. In 6/8, every note occupies one of the bar’s two main beats, so the ascent takes three complete bars. Their equal duration gives the listener time to register each interval. This is not a decorative flourish that passes too quickly for its details to be heard.

G and B flat initially suggest the tonic minor chord, but the continuation does not complete a straightforward arpeggio. E flat moves to F sharp, and the second B flat to C sharp: both are augmented seconds. F sharp to B flat is a diminished fourth. Those intervals account for the line’s unusual shape more precisely than calling it random. They also distinguish an unconventional tonal melody from music without a tonal framework.

Bar 4 changes the rate of movement. The line descends through D, C natural, B flat, A, G and F sharp in quavers, reaching G at the beginning of bar 5. C natural cancels the preceding C sharp; F sharp now has a clear role in leading back to G. The subject therefore combines an unorthodox ascent with a conclusion that establishes a recognisable tonal direction. G minor is clarified within the opening phrase, rather than withheld until the end of the entire work.

Scarlatti K.30, bars 1–4: G, B flat, E flat, F sharp, B flat, C sharp, followed by descending quavers
Example 1. K.30, bars 1–4: the slower ascent and the descending quavers. Both keyboard staves are shown. Edited by Pierre Gouin, Les Éditions Outremontaises, 2006, p. 98; IMSLP/WIMA, no. 132965, CC BY-SA 4.0. First four bars cropped for display; notation unchanged.

Example 1 makes the change of note values clear: compare the first three bars with the quicker descent in bar 4. After the arrival on G, the original voice continues in quavers, and the answer enters below it in bar 6, beginning on D. Listeners who do not read notation can still recognise the change: the slower ascending pattern returns beneath a line that has already become more active. The distinction in rhythmic values helps the new entry stand out without requiring a sudden change of volume.

Entries, voices and the two hands

With the answer on D, the dominant of G, the subject becomes part of a conversation between lines. The opening voice continues rather than falling silent, supplying counterpoint: a melodic continuation designed to work with the new statement. The slower ascent retains its identity, while the more mobile notes maintain continuity between its widely spaced attacks. Both layers matter to the effect.

Further entries carry the material into lower registers and enlarge the available texture. Hands and staves, however, are not reliable units for counting voices. A middle line may pass between the hands, while the right hand may have to sustain two independent strands. Conversely, several notes struck together do not necessarily constitute several autonomous melodies. The performer’s practical division of the keyboard and the listener’s experience of polyphony are related, but different.

Calling K.30 a four-voice fugue provides a broad orientation, not a description of every bar. At some moments separate lines are readily distinguishable; at others they are reinforced by chordal writing or parallel motion. What matters most in listening is the current location of the subject and the activity surrounding it. Insisting on four equally independent voices throughout would conceal the flexibility of Scarlatti’s keyboard writing.

Episodes and the continuity of harmony

If the complete subject were repeated without interruption, its characteristic ascent would gradually lose its ability to attract attention. Scarlatti creates space between statements through episodes, in which shorter patterns, quaver movement and sequences carry more of the argument. In a sequence, a recognisable figure is repeated at another pitch level, bringing the harmony with it. Its direction can be heard without identifying every chord along the way.

The subject’s slower head and quicker tail offer different possibilities for continuation. Dotted crotchets make a thematic entry conspicuous; quavers can move more readily between voices and extend the passage connecting one statement to another. It is unnecessary to claim that every accompanying pattern derives from the subject. The audible relationship between a recognisable thematic line and its moving surroundings is already a substantial source of coherence.

Accidentals continually alter the available harmonies and the direction of individual lines. Local cadences offer temporary points of rest, yet movement in another voice may carry on before that rest becomes definitive. Harmony consequently binds several entries into a longer span. A returning subject need not feel like a fresh beginning: it can arrive within a process already under way, acquiring direction from what the other voices have been doing.

This distinction is useful when an entry seems less obvious than the opening one. Rather than assuming that the theme has disappeared into a decorative texture, listen for its broader rhythmic profile and the bass supporting it. The subject and the harmony need not attract equal attention at every moment. Their changing balance contributes to the fugue’s continuity.

6/8, held notes and tension within a steady tempo

The combination of Moderato and 6/8 calls for neither an immobile tread nor an automatically buoyant dance rhythm. Two broad beats should remain perceptible, allowing the dotted crotchets of the subject to retain their shape. Within those beats, six quavers provide a finer level of motion. The fugue can thus sustain different rates of activity simultaneously, without an actual change of tempo.

Tied notes extend through the movement of other parts, shifting emphasis beyond an expected beat. Where a held note becomes dissonant against a new harmony and subsequently resolves, tension depends on the relation between pitches and the timing of that resolution. The performer needs to keep the waiting note audible without slowing the entire phrase at every such point. Inner parts require particular care: the busier outer lines can otherwise cover the dissonance and its release.

On a keyboard, that care involves listening beyond the moment of attack. A note may cease to be physically prominent while its harmonic function remains active. Preserving that function, through duration and the balance of surrounding notes, makes the counterpoint more intelligible than uniformly stressing each new entry.

The closing bass and the final B natural

Towards the close, the bass assumes a more stable supporting role while the upper parts continue to move. Extended dominant and tonic foundations change the balance between harmonic travel and remaining in place. The underlying note may persist or be repeated, yet the combinations above it continue to develop. This is a pedal point: a sustained or recurring pitch supporting changing harmonies. The term does not refer to the sustaining pedal of the modern piano.

The final cadence confirms G, but its chord contains B natural, rather than B flat. The fugue therefore concludes with a major tonic, the familiar practice known as a Picardy third. This is not the beginning of a separate section in G major. It changes the quality of the closing chord: the third above G widens, while the tonal foundation stays in place.

A performance that treats the ending solely as an opportunity to increase volume can miss this particular change. A clear bass, movement sustained towards the cadence and an audible final third are more revealing than an arbitrary theatrical finish. Tonal stability completes the work, while the major chord distinguishes its final sonority from the minor-key point of departure.

A fugue as the final Essercizio

The collection’s title need not confine its contents to mechanical studies. In K.30 the technical challenge includes organising several audible levels at once: sustaining one voice, articulating another and bringing in a new statement without breaking the phrase. Polyphonic hearing is part of the required virtuosity, for both performer and listener.

Placed at the end of the sequence, the fugue offers a different demonstration of compositional ingenuity. Scarlatti’s freedom of harmonic movement operates within a recognisable process of imitation. No undocumented programme of a “final statement” has to be attributed to him to explain the change of character. The position in the collection, the Moderato marking and the fugal writing provide the necessary evidence.

Harpsichord and piano: different means of achieving clarity

The harpsichord is the secure starting point because the printed collection names it. Unlike the modern piano, it does not grade volume in direct response to key pressure. Differences between voices depend principally on duration, articulation, small timing adjustments and, where the instrument permits, registration. Releasing an accompanying note can reveal a new entry more effectively than attempting to make that entry louder.

The pianist can establish separate dynamic levels, but must preserve the different functions of the lines. Continuous legato across all parts and extensive sustaining pedal can join notes whose independence matters. Working first with individual voices, then with pairs, helps establish which notes remain active and which have completed their role. This does not prescribe a single interpretation. Historical context supplies criteria, while the resources of each instrument require their own practical decisions.

Research into the keyboards known to Scarlatti has broadened the discussion beyond a simple opposition between harpsichord and modern grand piano. That wider inquiry should nevertheless be distinguished from a specific claim about K.30. The existence of early pianos in his historical environment does not, by itself, establish that this particular fugue was composed for one.

🪶 A Chapter in the Life of the Work

An unfinished copy preserves the cat story

An eighteenth-century musical manuscript now held by the Bibliothèque nationale de France as D-18365 contains three Scarlatti sonatas copied by an anonymous hand. For K.30, the copyist used 3/8 rather than 6/8. The transcription stops around the middle of the work; further staves prepared for music remain empty. Why the task was abandoned is unknown.

An English annotation added above the fugue reports that its subject was said to have come from a cat walking on a harpsichord. It records a story already in circulation, rather than identifying an eyewitness. It gives no name for the animal and says nothing about “Pulcinella”. Nevertheless, the unfinished copy preserved a connection absent from the title of the first printed edition.

In the early nineteenth century, Muzio Clementi included the music in the second volume of his Selection of Practical Harmony. His description presented it as the celebrated “Cat’s Fugue”, treating the nickname as something already recognisable. The work had entered an anthology for organ or piano, alongside contrapuntal music by earlier composers. Its short accompanying story could now travel with it into another educational and publishing setting.

The concert piano provided a further route to listeners. Franz Liszt played the fugue at the Berlin Singakademie on 16 January 1842, in a programme also featuring his Mazeppa and a fantasy on themes from Bellini’s La sonnambula. By then the animal had an established place in the title. An audience member could remember the “Cat’s Fugue” without knowing the collection in which the piece had first appeared.

In 2019, the musicologist Rudolf Rasch described the Paris manuscript in an article primarily concerned with an aria by Vivaldi. His observation about K.30 corrected a persistent gap in its familiar history: the cat tradition predates Clementi. The incomplete copy did not authenticate an incident in Scarlatti’s home. It supplied an earlier, identifiable witness to the story, allowing the history of its circulation to be separated from the truth of the event it describes.

🎧 Listening Guide

On a first hearing, remember the contrast between the six slow notes at the opening and the descent that follows. Feel two broad beats in each bar: the initial pitches advance one per beat, while the descending line divides that same time into smaller values. Rhythm will then help identify the subject when it returns in a different register.

When the lower answer begins on D, follow it for a while and allow the upper line to become a second level. On another hearing, reverse your attention: listen to the original voice continuing above the new statement. This makes the difference between counterpoint and a melody with straightforward accompaniment easier to hear.

Where the complete slow ascent is less conspicuous, attend to recurring quaver patterns. If a figure is repeated higher or lower, follow the direction of the sequence. You do not need to name each key to hear that the harmony is moving, or to notice when a cadence briefly brings it to rest.

Near the ending, concentrate on the bass. Notice when it stays on, or repeatedly returns to, the same pitch while the upper parts remain active. Then listen for B natural above G in the final chord. That major third is a more precise point of attention than a general impression that the conclusion sounds brighter.

🎶 Further Listening

These documented recordings offer a useful comparison of instruments and interpretative priorities. The suggestions below identify features to compare, rather than assigning a single ideal reading to the work.

  • Scott Ross — harpsichord, The Complete Keyboard Works, Vol. 1, K.1–30: hear K.30 after the preceding sonatas to register the shift from rapid keyboard activity to sustained contrapuntal listening. Concentrate on how duration and articulation distinguish its entries.
  • Ottavio Dantone — harpsichord, Keyboard Sonatas, Complete, Vol. 8, Stradivarius STR33655: compare note lengths and the small breaths at cadences with Ross. Sharing an instrument does not require two performers to organise the phrases in the same way.
  • Yevgeny Sudbin — piano, Scarlatti: Piano Sonatas, BIS-1508, 2005: follow the possibilities of dynamic separation between the thematic line and moving inner parts. Comparison with the harpsichord reveals what changes when the volume of individual notes becomes an independent expressive resource.

📚 Further Reading

  • Ralph Kirkpatrick — Domenico Scarlatti (Princeton University Press, 1953): a foundational guide to sources, cataloguing and the sonatas’ place in Scarlatti’s output. Its historical importance makes it a starting point to be read alongside subsequent research.
  • W. Dean Sutcliffe — The Keyboard Sonatas of Domenico Scarlatti and Eighteenth-Century Musical Style (Cambridge University Press, 2003): a substantial framework for understanding syntax, rhythm and unconventional choices across the sonatas, beyond the particular anecdote attached to K.30.
  • Rudolf Rasch — Lost and Found: “Apri le luci e mira”, an Aria from Vivaldi’s Opera “Ginevra, principessa di Scozia” (2019): especially pp. 73–74, where manuscript D-18365 supplies earlier evidence for the cat tradition. A useful example of source research correcting a familiar account.
  • Jacqueline Esther Ogeil — Domenico Scarlatti: A Contribution to Our Understanding of His Sonatas through Performance and Research (PhD dissertation, 2006): explores keyboard compass, historical temperaments and the suitability of different instruments; K.30 receives specific discussion on p. 94.

🔗 Related Works

  • Domenico Scarlatti — Fugue in C minor, K.58: a reminder that fugal writing extends beyond K.30 and its nickname. Compare the subject’s shape and the ways in which entries are connected.
  • Johann Sebastian Bach — Fugue in G minor, BWV 861, from Book I of The Well-Tempered Clavier: the shared key and different thematic outline provide a clear basis for comparing entries and continuity, without turning the comparison into a ranking of composers.
  • George Frideric Handel — Concerto grosso, Op. 6 No. 3, HWV 321, second movement: its often-discussed intervallic resemblance to Scarlatti invites comparison by ear. Resemblance alone does not establish direct borrowing.
  • Anton Reicha — Fugue No. 9 from Trente-six fugues: the relationship is explicit here, through the adoption of a subject by Scarlatti. Published in 1803, the collection places older thematic material within a different programme of compositional exploration.
  • Amy Beach — Fantasia fugata, Op. 87: published in 1923 and linked with the cat Hamlet and the familiar Scarlatti story. It continues the idea of a feline-generated subject, rather than reproducing K.30’s notes.

🎼 Closing Reflection

A memorable nickname can introduce us to music we might never otherwise seek out. After that first encounter, our attention can change: we begin to anticipate an entry, recognise a line we previously lost, or hear the final chord more distinctly. The cat can remain part of the story without occupying the whole experience. Scarlatti’s unfamiliar subject is worth following even when we stop trying to imagine the circumstances of its invention.

📖 Bibliography and Sources

The analysis is based on direct examination of Gouin’s edition, with the opening and final chord checked against the digitised first-edition facsimile. The history of the cat tradition draws on Rasch’s specific study of manuscript D-18365, distinguishing evidence for the age of the story from authentication of its supposed event. Recording recommendations were identified through label catalogues. Kirkpatrick’s and Sutcliffe’s monographs are recommended in Further Reading, rather than presented as books examined in full for this revision.

Scores and transmission sources

Scarlatti, Domenico. Essercizi per gravicembalo, Sonata XXX, “Fuga”, pp. 107–110. London: B. Fortier, undated [c.1738–1739]. Reprinted in Complete Keyboard Works in Facsimile, Vol. 1, New York: Johnson Reprint Corporation, 1972. Digital copy: IMSLP no. 461758.

Scarlatti, Domenico. Essercizio 30: Fuga, edited by Pierre Gouin. Montréal: Les Éditions Outremontaises, 2006, pp. 98–101. IMSLP/Werner Icking Music Collection, no. 132965, CC BY-SA 4.0. Source of Example 1; the opening and ending were checked against the first-edition facsimile.

Recueil d’arias d’opéra et de pièces de clavecin. Bibliothèque nationale de France, département de la Musique, D-18365, especially ff. 18v–20r. Manuscript transmission of K.30 and the cat annotation, as examined by Rudolf Rasch.

Clementi, Muzio, editor. Selection of Practical Harmony, for the Organ or Piano Forte, Vol. 2, pp. 155–157. London: Clementi & Co., early nineteenth century. The entry and its dating are discussed by Rasch; the anthology appeared in successive volumes.

Studies consulted

Rasch, Rudolf. “Lost and Found: ‘Apri le luci e mira’, an Aria from Vivaldi’s Opera Ginevra, principessa di Scozia.” Studi vivaldiani 19 (2019): 65–84, especially 73–74. Fondazione Giorgio Cini, Istituto Italiano Antonio Vivaldi.

Ogeil, Jacqueline Esther. Domenico Scarlatti: A Contribution to Our Understanding of His Sonatas through Performance and Research. PhD dissertation, 30 June 2006, especially pp. 73–74 and 94. Digital text hosted by Denzil Wraight.

Publishing, recording and digital documentation

Classical Pianists. Franz Liszt — Chronology VIII, entry for 16 January 1842, Singakademie, Berlin. Digital reconstruction of concert chronology; consulted for this specific performance of K.30.

Casa Ricordi. Domenico Scarlatti — Critical Edition of the Harpsichord Sonatas. Official account of editorial method and published volumes; consulted to check series information, not as a substitute for examination of the critical apparatus.

Warner Classics. Scarlatti: The Complete Keyboard Works, Vol. 1: Sonatas, Kk.1–30 “Essercizi”, Scott Ross. Official recording entry.

Stradivarius/Naxos. Scarlatti: Keyboard Sonatas (Complete), Vol. 8, Ottavio Dantone, STR33655. Official track listing.

BIS Records. Scarlatti: Piano Sonatas, Yevgeny Sudbin, BIS-1508, 2005, track 9: K.30. Official recording information.

Bärenreiter. Anton Reicha, 36 Fugues for Piano, edited by Václav Jan Sýkora, BA 9541. Publisher documentation of the collection and its 1803 first edition.

Johnson, Kirsten. Notes to Amy Beach: Piano Music, Volume III — The Mature Years, Guild GMCD 7351. For the 1923 publication of Fantasia fugata and its connection with the cat Hamlet.

IMSLP / Petrucci Music Library. Entries for K.30, Essercizi per gravicembalo and Selection of Practical Harmony. Consulted for source identification, publication details and access to the musical texts examined. Digital resources accessed 20 October 2026.