![]() |
| In the first Valse oubliée, Liszt keeps the dance alive at the piano as the brilliance of the salon gradually recedes into memory. |
Work Information
- Composer:
- Franz Liszt (1811–1886)
- Title:
- Valse oubliée No. 1 in F-sharp major, S. 215/1
- Year of composition:
- 1881; autograph dated 23 July
- First edition:
- 1881, Bote & Bock, Berlin and Posen
- Genre:
- Waltz for solo piano
- Musical period:
- Romanticism; Liszt’s late period
- Structure:
- Continuous episodic form with transformed returns
- Duration:
- approx. 2½–4 minutes
- Instrumentation:
- Solo piano
Franz Liszt’s Valse oubliée No. 1, S. 215/1, sets the elegance of a salon waltz against the restless harmonic language of his later years. The dance retains its grace and vitality, yet its character changes repeatedly: chromatic shifts, sharply detached chords and contrasts of articulation unsettle the familiar rhythm. Towards the end, the accompaniment gradually disappears, leaving a single unaccompanied melodic line. This movement from a richly worked piano texture to an exposed ending gives the short piece its distinctive expressive weight.
Liszt wrote the piece in the summer of 1881, only months before his seventieth birthday. His great touring years were behind him, but composition and piano teaching still occupied much of his life. Here the virtuoso’s fluency meets an increasingly economical musical language: a few recognisable ideas produce striking contrasts in the space of only a few minutes.
The French title means “forgotten waltz.” Liszt had also used the adjective in Romance oubliée, a work prompted by the return of an old manuscript that he then substantially reworked. No equivalent recovery of an earlier completed composition has been established for this waltz. Its title chiefly invites us to consider how a newly written piece might look back upon an older musical world.
The first waltz had its own publication history before becoming part of a group of four Valses oubliées, composed by 1884. These pieces were not planned as a cycle. The singular Première Valse oubliée identifies the present work; the plural belongs to the group. Of the four, the first has remained the most widely performed.
Nostalgia is a persuasive starting point, provided it leaves room for the music’s sharpness. Clipped chords, a teasing scherzando, an impassioned melody and rapid trills all have their place. The central question is how the dance holds together while its harmonic support, keyboard density and returning themes undergo such substantial changes.
Movements / Structure
This is a continuous work of 209 measures in 3/4, initially marked Allegro. The regions below form an analytical map rather than separate movements. The return of the opening divides two broad phases, but the second substantially redirects the course and conclusion of the first.
| Measures | Region | Place in the work |
|---|---|---|
| 1–16 | Chordal introduction | Clipped chords, rests and a short melodic lead-in. |
| 17–48 | First waltz region | F-sharp major; a wide-ranging melody and relocation of its material. |
| 49–106 | Scherzando and lyrical climax | Contrasting articulation; ff appassionato from m. 89. |
| 107–139 | Return and altered waltz | The introduction returns; the theme re-enters with two flats from m. 124. |
| 140–159 | Repeated figures and trills | Melodic continuity contracts as movement becomes concentrated. |
| 160–209 | Lyrical return and withdrawal | Soft melody above triplets; an unaccompanied line from m. 193. |
Coherence depends above all on transformed returns. The lyrical melody’s reappearance at measure 160 is especially significant: an idea previously projected with force comes back quietly, carried by a different accompaniment. From this point, the music gradually withdraws towards its unaccompanied close.
Musical Analysis
The introduction: clipped chords and shifting weight
The opening sixteen measures prepare the dance without immediately supplying its familiar accompaniment. Pairs of chords, interrupted by rests and marked staccato, establish an incisive pattern of short, separated sounds. Their downward movement gives the interrupted material a clear direction. Both hands contribute to these coordinated attacks; the division into melody and accompaniment has yet to settle.
The metre is 3/4 from the outset, but the rests and changing placement of the chords prevent an unvarying “one–two–three” from taking hold. The introduction also begins without a key signature, with accidentals supplied beside individual notes. The six-sharp signature arrives with the principal waltz. Its initial absence is not evidence of atonality; it simply warns against treating the work’s home key as a sufficient description of every passage.
Example 1 reproduces the first eight measures. The articulation dots and written rests show why the opening needs distinct edges. In this edition, p specifies dynamic level, whereas staccato governs the separation and sounding length of the chords. A chord can be quiet and still speak with considerable definition.
![]() |
| Example 1 — Valse oubliée No. 1, mm. 1–8, complete piano texture. Staccato dots and rests organise the chordal opening. José Vianna da Motta edition, Musikalische Werke II/10, Breitkopf & Härtel, 1928, p. 165, plate F.L. 103. Bayerische Staatsbibliothek digitisation, via IMSLP #30916. |
A short melodic lead-in at measures 15–16, marked con grazia, changes the music’s breathing before the first theme. The opening chords thus serve a precise formal purpose: they create an expectation that the dance will fulfil. When they return much later, their distinctive spacing helps the listener recognise the beginning of a second large phase.
The first waltz: a wide leap and flexible accompaniment
At measure 17, the dance settles into a clearer pulse. The six-sharp signature establishes F-sharp major, while the left hand supports a melody built around wide intervals. Yet the accompaniment is more flexible than a conventional bass note followed by two chords: its rests and connections between notes leave space for the melody to unfold without a mechanically repeated pattern.
The melodic outline includes a major ninth, an interval extending a little beyond an octave. That reach opens the phrase upwards before it turns towards a more flowing descent. A listener can follow the contrast between the leap and the subsequent continuous motion without needing to identify individual pitches.
Eight-measure groupings provide a familiar sense of proportion. Liszt then uses that framework to move the material to a higher level. Because the shape remains recognisable, the listener experiences both continuity and a change of harmonic position. The dance proceeds through the relocation of its material rather than simply repeating a closed paragraph at the same pitch.
Chromatic notes give this movement its particular tension. A melodic note does not always agree immediately with the supporting chord, and the expected resolution may be postponed. Such brief delays keep the graceful phrase in motion. An excessively slow performance can magnify each local hesitation until the larger sweep of the waltz becomes difficult to hear.
The scherzando: character shaped through articulation
The scherzando begins quietly at measure 49, with lively eighth-note motion. In the right hand, an insistent moving figure accompanies more prominent upper notes; the left supplies bass notes and brief chordal supports. After the broader melodic lines of the first waltz, attention shifts towards small contrasts in articulation and the interplay between voices.
The distinction between legato and staccato is crucial. Some groups are joined under slurs; other notes are explicitly detached. Equalising their lengths, or covering the passage with continuous pedal, removes the contrasts that make the episode witty. Its lightness comes from specific differences in sound rather than from a general instruction to play delicately.
As the section unfolds, the motion is repeated at different pitches and the writing acquires greater weight. A gentler melodic preparation intervenes before the climax, followed by an ascending passage. The route to the appassionato therefore involves changes of texture and direction, renewing the energy rather than merely increasing the volume throughout.
The appassionato: a singing line above the dance
At measure 89, ff appassionato introduces the strongest lyrical statement. The melody is projected in octaves high on the keyboard and the accompaniment becomes denser. Repeated eighth notes move beneath chordal supports, giving the sustained melodic line an active foundation.
Ties and phrases extending across bar lines give the melody greater continuity. The 3/4 pulse remains, but the listener’s attention moves from the dance step to the shape of the singing phrase. In the records of his teaching, Liszt described this region as elegiac. That character is entirely compatible with its fortissimo marking: the elegiac feeling is expressed here with considerable force.
This is not a separate slow movement. The passage remains part of the work’s continuous motion, and its formal importance becomes clearer in retrospect. When the same melody returns softly, its contour will establish the relationship even as the changed accompaniment makes it seem more distant.
The opening returns, followed by an altered ninth
The clipped introductory chords reappear at measure 107, identifiable through their rhythm, rests and outline. Here the six-sharp signature is cancelled; the two flats of the following thematic region have not yet arrived. The distinction matters because the return of the introductory material stands between those two notational changes.
When the principal waltz reappears at measure 124, the key signature has two flats. This does not establish an unchanging B-flat major or G minor throughout the passage: additional accidentals and the movement of the voices keep the harmony in flux. The familiar theme is chromatically displaced, and its characteristic major ninth returns as a minor ninth, creating a more acute dissonance.
A difference of one semitone changes the melody’s relationship to its support. The theme remains sufficiently intact to be recognised, while its harmonic perspective has shifted. This is why an A–B–A′ description needs substantial qualification: the second appearance of A is a reworking that prepares a different continuation, rather than a straightforward recovery of the opening state.
From repeated notes to trills
Around measure 140, complete melodic curves give way to repeated pairs of notes. The smaller figure concentrates the movement within a narrow compass. The accompaniment thins, and the return of the six-sharp signature brings the music back towards its principal tonal orientation.
Repeated figures and exchanges between the hands lead to trills—rapid alternations of neighbouring notes. The metre remains 3/4, but so much of the customary waltz accompaniment has disappeared that the dance pulse is less immediately apparent. Virtuosity temporarily moves away from presenting a complete theme and becomes a means of transition.
These rapid figures prepare a decisive change in texture. The trills might suggest another powerful climax, but Liszt takes the music in the opposite direction: their accumulated energy leads to the quiet return of the lyrical melody.
The transformation at measure 160 and the unaccompanied close
At measure 160, the appassionato melody returns with a p marking. Its accompaniment now flows in eighth-note triplets: three notes occupy each beat in place of the two eighth notes of the earlier forceful statement. Together with the quieter dynamic, the change turns a dense lyrical outpouring into a more fluid keyboard texture.
The melody retains its octaves and recognisable contour, while the accompaniment moves across a wider span. Balancing the singing upper line against the broken chords becomes a central performance question. A heavy left hand obscures the change of scale distinguishing this return from the first appassionato. If the melody fades prematurely, the long phrase breaks up before the music’s actual withdrawal has begun.
As the piece approaches its end, the melodic note values lengthen, the movement subsides and the accompaniment finally stops. From measure 193, the score still uses two staves, but only one unaccompanied melodic line is heard, passed between the hands. It does not stay in the upper register: short melodic arcs connect different levels, with rests allowing the resonance of each phrase to register.
Dolcissimo and the concluding un poco ritenuto ask for sweetness and a slight slowing. The final note is F-sharp, the tonic, unsupported by a complete chord. Tonal arrival is therefore present, although confirmed with the smallest possible means. The coda completes the form by gradually removing the elements that had made the dance a richly accompanied keyboard image.
Tonal orientation and harmonic uncertainty
The label F-sharp major identifies the first Valse oubliée’s main tonal orientation and its eventual arrival. Along the way, however, the opening has no key signature, the principal theme returns in a chromatically altered form and some resolutions are delayed. The sense of tonal stability changes from one region to another.
A key signature tells us how pitches are notated; understanding their tonal function also requires attention to the chords and the relationships between voices. The two flats at the waltz’s return do not, on their own, establish B-flat major throughout that section. Additional accidentals reshape the harmony, and a dissonance may sustain its tension before resolving without bringing tonal organisation to an end.
The returning theme’s minor ninth offers an audible example. The material remains familiar even though the distance between its crucial notes has narrowed. Harmonic estrangement has a specific musical basis here. Connections with Liszt’s broader late experiments are illuminating, provided every chromatic episode is not treated as synonymous with atonality.
Pianistic touch and the suggestion of memory
The title encourages us to hear the returns as recollections, but that remains an interpretative reading. The score supplies the means that make it convincing: altered intervals, a melody returning above a different accompaniment and the gradual removal of its harmonic support. No particular salon, individual or remembered dance occasion has been established as the subject of the piece.
Each texture demands a different kind of pianistic control. The opening chords need precisely timed releases; the scherzando requires clear separation between voices and between legato and staccato; the quiet lyrical return calls for a flowing accompaniment that never overwhelms the melody. Pedalling can enrich the sound, but it must follow harmonic changes without blurring the notated rests.
Virtuosity remains active in the trills and expansive keyboard writing. Its final challenge moves in the opposite direction: a few unaccompanied notes must retain continuity and purpose after almost the entire preceding texture has been withdrawn.
🪶 A Chapter in the Life of the Work
A crossed-out ending and two extra chords
The summer of 1881 found Franz Liszt recovering at his home in Weimar. He had fallen on the stairs on 2 July and spent weeks confined to bed. On 23 July, during that same difficult month, he dated the manuscript of a new piano piece. Its first page carries the simple title Valse. The word “forgotten”, by which the work would become known, had yet to appear.
The manuscript also preserves a substantial change of plan. On its ninth page, Liszt crossed out an original ending of 24 measures and replaced it with 50 new measures on the following two pages. The revision allowed the final stretch of music to unfold more gradually, until the texture was reduced to a lone melodic line. The pages tell us exactly what was replaced, although they offer no explanation of why Liszt chose to rewrite it.
Less than a month later, the waltz was already the subject of correspondence with a publisher. On 9 August, Liszt offered it to Hugo Bock of the music-publishing firm Bote & Bock, now using German and French titles that both meant “forgotten waltz”. After receiving the fee he had requested, he wrote on 8 September authorising the engraving of the score. The first edition appeared before the end of 1881.
The cover reinforced the idea carried by the new title. A memorial tablet, flowers, a sleeping allegorical figure and a ribbon inscribed Souvenir gave the edition the imagery of remembrance. The music itself was newly written; no specific lost composition or remembered dance has been established as its subject. When the publisher brought the first three Valses oubliées together in 1884, the waltz of 1881 acquired the designation Première.
Four years later, the piece reappears in the record of Liszt’s teaching. On 10 July 1885, August Göllerich, a pianist and pupil who kept notes on Liszt’s lessons, played the first two Valses oubliées. Liszt made a self-mocking remark about their harmonic liberties, as though they were the work of someone ignorant of academic rules. His humour did not make his performing instructions any less exacting.
For the first waltz, he wanted the opening chords sharply detached and the connected phrases of the second theme clearly distinguished from the shorter ones. At the close, his attention turned to the absence of a final chord. Audiences, he observed, liked to hear such a concluding reassurance; jokingly, he allowed a few chords to be added. Göllerich records that Liszt himself supplied two, in the appropriate key.
That brief episode is revealing precisely because the printed score ends otherwise. Göllerich recorded an exchange during a lesson, not a newly notated ending, and the two chords are no evidence of an authorised revision. Liszt plainly understood the expectation of a full, conventional cadence. His joke played on the difference between that expectation and the ending he had chosen for the work.
On 18 February 1886, seven months after the earlier lesson, Göllerich’s notes return to the same waltz. Liszt still wanted the opening chords very short and clearly defined, with the first theme moving forward rather than becoming unduly slow. The scherzando called for a freely playful manner; the forceful lyrical passage needed an elegiac quality, its dance character kept in the background.
For the trills he asked for speed and acceleration, while the final return of the melody required sorrow and sensitivity. These are records of lessons, not a later edition of the score. They show how closely Liszt continued to attend to the piece’s changing moods in his final years. The ending he had rewritten in 1881 remained a passage he cared to shape in performance.
🎧 Listening Guide
For a first hearing, follow the alternation between a recognisable dance accompaniment and passages where that support recedes. Measure numbers provide additional orientation for readers with the score, but the following landmarks can also be recognised by ear.
The clipped opening. Hear the chords together with the little silences separating them. Before a continuous melody arrives, rhythm comes from the exchange between sound and rest. Remember the outline: it returns at measure 107.
The dance and the leap. From measure 17, accompaniment and a broader melodic curve make the waltz more immediately apparent. Follow the melody’s wide opening and subsequent descent. On a second hearing, compare this region with its altered reappearance after the introductory chords return.
The playful episode. At measure 49, the music grows more mobile and varied in articulation. Notice the difference between a connected group and a succession of short, separated notes. Those small distinctions shape the scherzando character.
Two lyrical statements. The forceful melody at measure 89 comes back softly at measure 160. Recognise its contour, then shift attention to the accompaniment: the later statement flows in triplets, redistributing the movement more fluidly.
Trills as a transition. Just before the quiet lyrical return, rapid alternations of neighbouring notes temporarily loosen the sense of a regular dance phrase. Follow the way their energy leads into a soft dynamic rather than a final outburst.
An ending without accompaniment. From measure 193, one melodic line passes between the hands. Allow the final F-sharp to fade fully. The missing final chord becomes especially apparent if you remember the density of the first appassionato.
🎶 Further Listening
These recordings of the same work offer comparisons in articulation, temporal freedom and the scale of the lyrical return. The differences are especially revealing if you listen to the scherzando and the final page in succession.
- Vladimir Horowitz — The Studio Recordings, New York 1985, Deutsche Grammophon. Strongly differentiated touch and flexible phrasing sharpen the distance between the dance’s teasing manner and the coda’s sensitivity. Notice how small displacements of time alter the weight of a phrase.
- Leslie Howard — Liszt: The Complete Music for Solo Piano, Vol. 1 — Waltzes, Hyperion CDA66201, recorded October 1985. Its place within a survey of Liszt’s waltzes allows the piece to be heard beside the other three Valses oubliées. The clear succession of episodes is particularly useful for following the thematic returns.
- Stephen Hough — Stephen Hough in recital, Hyperion CDA67686, recorded July 2008. Elastic movement and finely balanced keyboard layers offer another perspective on the relationship between melody and accompaniment. Listen for the way the quiet return sustains the long phrase without weighing down the pulse.
📚 Further Reading
Further study benefits from distinguishing the musical text, records of teaching and broader biographical context. Each of the following sources serves a different purpose.
- Mária Eckhardt — Preface to Valses oubliées, Henle HN 977. It brings together the publication history and extracts from Liszt’s lessons, matching page references in the old Bote & Bock editions to modern measure numbers.
- Peter Jost — Comments to Valses oubliées, Henle HN 977. The critical apparatus explains the relationship between manuscripts and first editions and precisely describes the replacement of the original ending.
- August Göllerich — Franz Liszts Klavierunterricht von 1884–1886, edited by Wilhelm Jerger. The records place performing instructions within the context of Liszt’s lessons; pages 84 and 127 concern the first Valse oubliée specifically.
- Alan Walker — Franz Liszt, Volume III: The Final Years, 1861–1886. An extensive biographical setting for the late music, Liszt’s relationships and his teaching. Recommended as a next reading, it complements the score and the work’s specific critical documentation.
🔗 Related Works
Other approaches to the waltz illuminate both the distance from Liszt’s earlier writing and the place of remembered dance in the piano repertoire.
- Franz Liszt — Valse-Impromptu, S. 213: A waltz from the younger Liszt’s world, rich in outward elegance, lyrical ease and keyboard brilliance.
- Franz Liszt — Valse oubliée No. 2, S. 215/2: The next piece moves further from an immediately recognisable waltz pulse through sharp rhythmic contrasts and unusual tonal shifts.
- Frédéric Chopin — Waltz in A minor, Op. 34 No. 2: A melancholy transformation of social dance into inward expression, retaining clearer periodicity and formal balance.
- Claude Debussy — La plus que lente: A later, ironically stylised view of the salon waltz, where sensual slowness and harmonic fluidity carry a subtle distance from the genre.
- Maurice Ravel — Valses nobles et sentimentales: A sequence of waltzes shaped by pungent harmony, constant changes of character and a final recollection in which earlier episodes return as fragments of memory.
🎼 Closing Reflection
When the last note arrives, let your hands remain still for a moment. Resonance continues something the notation has already brought to an end. In that interval, the dance may return to your memory in all its motion, although the piano has only one sound left to give.
📖 Bibliography and Sources
The analysis was checked against the historical Musikalische Werke edition and the Neue Liszt-Ausgabe, alongside Henle’s critical commentary. Historical research used the Library of Congress presentation of the manuscript’s opening and the correspondence and lesson records reproduced in Mária Eckhardt’s preface. Indirect access to those historical texts is identified below.
Scores and critical editions
Liszt, Franz. Erster vergessener Walzer / Première Valse oubliée, in Musikalische Werke, Series II, Volume 10, edited by José Vianna da Motta. Leipzig: Breitkopf & Härtel, 1928, pp. 165–170, plate F.L. 103. Digital copy: IMSLP #30916, from a Bayerische Staatsbibliothek digitisation. Source of Example 1.
Liszt, Franz. Valses oubliées, Neue Liszt-Ausgabe, Series I, Volume 14, edited by Imre Mező and Imre Sulyok. Budapest: Editio Musica Budapest, 1984, plate Z.8858; first waltz, pp. 41–45. Digital copy: IMSLP #108674. Used to check measure numbering, key signatures, dynamics and accompaniment patterns.
Liszt, Franz. Valses oubliées, HN 977, edited by Peter Jost, fingering by Rolf Koenen, preface by Mária Eckhardt. Munich: G. Henle Verlag. Preface and critical commentary dated autumn 2010; especially pp. V–VI and 40–41.
Manuscript and historical accounts
Liszt, Franz. Valse, autograph manuscript, 23 July 1881. Washington: Library of Congress, Music Division, ML96 L58 Case. The opening was inspected through David H. Plylar’s digital presentation; the description of the deleted ending and added pages was checked through Peter Jost’s critical commentary.
Göllerich, August. Franz Liszts Klavierunterricht von 1884–1886, dargestellt an den Tagebuchaufzeichnungen von August Göllerich, edited by Wilhelm Jerger. Regensburg: Gustav Bosse, 1975, pp. 84 and 127. The relevant accounts were consulted as reproduced in Eckhardt’s preface, rather than through examination of the complete book.
Jung, Franz Rudolf, ed. Franz Liszt in seinen Briefen. Berlin, 1987, letters nos. 148–149 to Hugo Bock, 9 August and 8 September 1881. Publication details were used as cited in Eckhardt’s preface to HN 977.
Digital documentation and discography
Plylar, David H. “Unforgetting the Forgotten: Liszt’s Oubliéegatory Birthday Post.” In the Muse, Library of Congress, 22 October 2014.
G. Henle Verlag. Valses oubliées, HN 977: online presentation, preface and critical commentary. IMSLP. Valses oubliées, S. 215: edition records and digitised scores #30916 and #108674.
Deutsche Grammophon. Horowitz: The Studio Recordings, New York 1985. Hyperion Records. Liszt: The Complete Music for Solo Piano, Vol. 1 — Waltzes, Leslie Howard, CDA66201; Stephen Hough in recital, Stephen Hough, CDA67686. Label catalogue entries were used to identify the recommended recordings.

